Raid Finder Loot Rules Update

A decent solution, but it won't stop jerks from rolling need on something that they already have (or wearing better) if it's MS. I've had this happen on occasion in LFD, so I'm not expecting anything different from LFR.

how will this system work with rouges and feral tanks when we both have the same gear will we both get the bonus or not?

this sounds like a pretty good idea, though i can still see some drama over items that have stats valued by more than one role. but at least it's a step in the right direction in keeping dps from stealing tank loot, and other such situations.

there are goign to be SOOOO many QQ tears from all the greedy little pricks that feel entitled to rolling on anything they want

Originally Posted by frag971

So what prevents having all fury, cats, retris and frostDKs to select tanking role just before the pull and have +100 on that last item they want from that specific boss?

You can't change your role after you queue for a raid or dungeon, unless someone leaves and you have to requeue.

I like this idea, a lot

Originally Posted by Azrile

Blizzard drastically nerfed STR for feral druids a few patches ago.. I highly doubt they would give them the bonus 100 after basically already eliminating it as a viable option.

There are a lot of grey areas.. my guess is they are going to be as forgiving as possible with the items. But I wonder how precise they are going to be. Are they going to actually look at specs.. spriests get bonus 100 for spirit gear, but mages don´t? How about kitty dps getting bonus100 on moonkin gear (both in a dps role).. will mages get bonus100 on all cloth gear and healers not unless it has spirit?

With spirit, it will probably give bonuses to classes whose spec can either use it to heal, or convert spirit into hit for DPS, both of which Warlocks and Mages cannot.

I doubt dps will get a bonus to rolls if the gear doesn't have spirit on it, though they probably will get the bonus if the gear has +hit on it.

Originally Posted by Jagstang

With spirit, it will probably give bonuses to classes whose spec can either use it to heal, or convert spirit into hit for DPS, both of which Warlocks and Mages cannot.

i thought one of the mage armor buffs converted spirit to spell power or something?

Originally Posted by Moozart

i thought one of the mage armor buffs converted spirit to spell power or something?

You would have to ask a mage.

I like this idea. I hate going into a random and having some ass roll need on something for off-spec when myself or someone else needs it for main. At least when I decide to raid on my alts, they won't get screwed over by OS-needing pricks. (I do not mind when people ask if it's okay, but don't just need on the damn thing)

Originally Posted by Diasteel

how will this system work with rouges and feral tanks when we both have the same gear will we both get the bonus or not?

Answered here:

some items are flagged for more than one class role

Originally Posted by Alayea

A decent solution, but it won't stop jerks from rolling need on something that they already have (or wearing better) if it's MS. I've had this happen on occasion in LFD, so I'm not expecting anything different from LFR.

very true,but you still cut down a large amount of jerks/ninja.
+1 for the idea,too bad it took them(blizz) so long to come up with something like this,though I'm pretty sure I've seen the idea before,posted by a player/forum writer.

Originally Posted by Jagstang

With spirit, it will probably give bonuses to classes whose spec can either use it to heal, or convert spirit into hit for DPS, both of which Warlocks and Mages cannot.

from blizzard: "Please keep in mind that, at least for now, this system will only look at class role, and not player spec." so this argument is invalid. spec isn't factored in. 397 ivl stats > 359 ilvl stats. as such, a mage could see a spirit item as a huge upgrade, if only to reforge the spirit to hit.

More and more gear will have to be flagged as Unique to keep douche bag tanks from needing on it even when they have it already just to sell it. Wont stop the ones that have better doing it, but not much can be done about that I guess.

Originally Posted by Moozart

i thought one of the mage armor buffs converted spirit to spell power or something?

Molten Armor used to convert a spirit percentage into critical strike rating, it changed when 4.0 went live. So mages don't need spirit anymore and probably never will again.

Other than that, cool idea for Raid Finder.

It's better than not doing anything, that's for sure. However, unless we see updates to how Blizzard flags loot, it's only going to highlight Blizzard's failures in that area.

Currently, as a rogue, I can roll need on some strength items, trinkets and weapons generally. Theoretically, in this system, I can roll need as a DPS on a strength DPS trinket and have a guarantee to win it over a warrior/pally/dk tank who could actually use it as an off-spec as opposed to just being vendor trash for me. Same with spirit and mages. A mage can win spirit gear over a pally or druid tank, as many spirit items will be flagged as both DPS and healer items. Once again, vendor trash (and seriously sub-optimal gear) will win over somebody who could legitimately use the item as an off-spec.

Additionally, shamans and druids present another issue. Boomkins rolling on agility leather rolling on equal playing field to rogues and ferals, ele shammies rolling on hunter and enhance loot. This is a problem that exists now, of course, but the role feature just highlights it. Further, you can't separate it into melee and ranged DPS because agility mail is used by both, as are agility rings, trinkets, necks etc.

Once again, it's better than nothing, but it's not as good a step as the loot system detecting your current spec and off-spec and opening up MS Need and OS Need based on those instead. And they really need to revisit their flagging system, anyway.

Originally Posted by Noetical

I wonder whether hunters will have polearms as MS or if rogues will have bows/crossbows/guns as MS?Seams harsh on my feral druid to have to roll against a hunter for a polearm and im sure they feel the same way about rogues. Only thing is that everyone and their dog has a hunter lol.

While I understand your plight, hunters were using polearms since vanilla and druids didn't get them until BC. While I am not saying it is a "Hunter weapon" (As that kind of thought pattern pisses me off) I am thinking that one will be shared while the bow/gun/cross bow will be placed as MS for hunters since rogues use throwing weapons. o.0 Or should at least.

Originally Posted by Syrae

People that think like this: DPS warrior needs 2Hander, Blood tank needs 2Hander. Blood tank gets+100. Thats wrong. Items can be flagged for multi roles. So nobody gets+100 then. Only when a tank shield drops tanks get+100 as example. Bears are screwed then though because hunters need their pole arms and rogues need their gear

I don´t think any bear tank could consider it getting screwed over to lose a piece of leather armor to a rogue on a fair roll. What we don´t want to see is a bear tank losing a leather AGI piece too a restro druid, which this will prevent. I would be a little ´iffed´ if I lost an AGI staff to a hunter, but that is a minor thing. The much bigger issue is we won´t be losing dodge gear to undergeared hunters and rogues anymore.

Originally Posted by Doomrow

very true,but you still cut down a large amount of jerks/ninja.
+1 for the idea,too bad it took them(blizz) so long to come up with something like this,though I'm pretty sure I've seen the idea before,posted by a player/forum writer.

Why does everyone automatically think someone rolling for their offspec is a ninja/jerk?

All this will do is push geared and competent tanks into a dps role, where their gear is severely lacking, and geared and competent dps into a tanking role, where their gear is severely lacking.

Instead of queuing with your best geared spec you play the best at, it's queue up in your under geared, under performing other spec, cause some cry baby qq'd enough on the forums, never realizing what they were crying about.

You will see these same cry babies crying about bad tanks/healers queuing in dps gear, and bad dps, queuing in tank/healing gear.

---------- Post added 2011-10-07 at 12:13 PM ----------

Originally Posted by helheim

from blizzard: "Please keep in mind that, at least for now, this system will only look at class role, and not player spec." so this argument is invalid. spec isn't factored in. 397 ivl stats > 359 ilvl stats. as such, a mage could see a spirit item as a huge upgrade, if only to reforge the spirit to hit.

I am not arguing..... Please try to be original and not regurgitate some tired phrase you saw on 4chan seven months ago.

Originally Posted by Azrile

I don´t think any bear tank could consider it getting screwed over to lose a piece of leather armor to a rogue on a fair roll. What we don´t want to see is a bear tank losing a leather AGI piece too a restro druid, which this will prevent. I would be a little ´iffed´ if I lost an AGI staff to a hunter, but that is a minor thing. The much bigger issue is we won´t be losing dodge gear to undergeared hunters and rogues anymore.

What dodge items are you losing? Dodge was removed from most feral gear a while ago. You get it from agility, reforge and gem.