Originally Posted by
yurano
No, the real PvP fact is that Ret Paladins are underpowered. What everyone else in this thread seems to be doing is harping on nitpicky crap like "oh I hate getting silenced", "repentance is shit", and "FoL doesn't heal for shit" when other classes face the same exact challenges.
What if Ret Paladins couldn't be silenced? If repentance was instant? If FoL healed for more? None of those changes would make Ret paladins more balanced because they don't address any of the critical weaknesses of Ret. Instead, those changes would make Ret incredibly imbalanced (only good in certain instances like 1v1) which would end up with Ret getting nerfed into the ground as they are now.
Almost everyone posting in this thread has missed the big picture problem with Ret. Its not that Ret damage is weak or that Ret CC is poor. When balancing a spec, you must look at its entire toolkit as a whole, not focusing on its nitpicky and stupid points. The main weakness of Ret is its lack of defenses. Ret is exceptionally powerful when they're on the offensive, but when they get trained, they're just straight up screwed. This problem can be addressed in a variety of ways: second wind, shadow form, or an additional form of CC break (eg. bring back the stun removal effect of HoF).
A large part of why Blizzard won't fix Ret defense is because Ret's damage is too high. People who think Ret damage is fine are quite misguided because they have never been on the receiving end of Ret burst. Ret burst is on the same level as Frost Mage and Arms Warrior burst pre-nerf. The only reason Ret burst hasn't been nerfed yet is because Ret paladins aren't considered overpowered. If you give Ret more defenses without reducing their burst (at no cost to sustained damage) then Rets will become vastly overpowered (back to the first LK days). Whether or not Blizzard actually implements a change to trade some burst for defense is highly dependent on their bias.
TL;DR - Ret's weakness isn't because they get silenced and all the other crap like as everyone's been complaining about in this thread. Ret's primary weakness is their lack of defenses when getting trained. In exchange for additional defenses, Ret must give up some of their burst. People who blindly recommend a straight Ret buff without considering whole toolkit balance (especially offensive burst) is missing the big picture and largely the reason why Blizzard won't consider only a Ret buff.