Originally Posted by
Wyand1337
A lot of people in here seem to not have fully read the OP.
They did not equip themselves for 2 months and then formed a 10 man raid out of their best players, including a overpowered prot-paladin. They actually raided 25m for 6 weeks and then formed TWO 10 man groups, both doing extremely well, one group killing 3 new bosses and the other group killing 2 new bosses in the first week. The overpowered prot-paladin was in the "worse" group, that only managed to kill 2 new bosses.
So actually, they took at least 20 good players out of their 25 man raid (assuming everyone has a 100% raid attendance, so they only needed the best 20 players for this (lol) ) and had extremely good results. According to the OP, their 25m raid (wich could mathematically only contain a maximum of 5 bad players, according to your logic) only managed to kill 3 heroic bosses during their 6 weeks of heroic raiding and then, all of a sudden, they could take down 2-3 new bosses in one week. Sure, that must have been those 1-2 bad players in their 25m group (damn, that is incompatible to the "25m can carry a few bads"-thing, btw). Especially for a boss like council, where they could just let their bad players die und finish the boss without them due to their super inflated item-level.
I don't really care about the whole 10 vs 25 thing, but the arguments of the 'don't-insult-my-10man-elite!'-crowd in this thread are just nonsense. You didn't even read the OP and just make things up.