After deciding to contribute to the tribunal I headed up there eagerly to help make LoL a better place. I read all the cases page by page and tried to be a fair judge. After two days I checked my justice rating. I was baffled (If I recall correctly) looking at around 60-66%.
This felt really odd and I checked the cases I got wrong. After further review all the cases I got wrong were the people that I pardoned. I decided to do a little experiment. The following days I logged onto the tribunal and punished everybody without even reading what the reports said about the people. After a few days of testing this my accuracy is currently peaking around 93%.
I am sorry for all the people that I wronged with this, however I wasn't the only one given you need a majority for punishment. I just get the feeling that people don't even bother reading anymore and auto-punish everybody.
Thought I'd share this since it really confuses me. People can't be all that bad can they?
Update: After one more day my accuracy is currently at 93,9 %. Keep in mind that the 6% of wrong reports are mostly due to my "wrong" pardons. Instead of my wrong "punishs".