Originally Posted by
clevin
So have I. And killed him.
Your scenario still means that 2/3 of the players are doing poor DPS for even the minimum ilevel for SoO. You want to reward that by letting them win. I want to see them doing at least the basics right. Not perfectly, but basically right. After all, every single player in there has leveled that character ninety levels. Then geared the character well enough to be able to queue for SoO. At that point they should know the core spells to use when DPSing. All I'm asking is that they use those in a mostly correct rotation. It's LFR, they don't need to be using every ability precisely on cooldown, but I've seen mages, locks and hunters doing 30-50k dps. That's not even close to what those classes can do at 496 and no, I don't think they should be able to beat the boss when they're playing that poorly. They don't need to be pulling 100k+, but 60-80k is perfectly doable for someone who's basically competent.