Originally Posted by
Skroe
Sure. Absolutely. Let's be relentless. Let's have a reputation for being relentless. No argument there.
But this fiction about torture is utterly ridiculous. When the US used Torture after 2001 for a few years it was to extract information. Okay find. A warcrime. Terribly illegal. But let's concede, the motive was to prevent future terrorism.
What I'm seeing, and not isolated, is now this desire from particularly Trumps supporters is for torture as a form of punishment, even as a deterrent effect. That's a huge step beyond what the Bush Administration did. It's vastly worse. You can say torture for intelligence gathering is deeply flawed, horrifically illegal, monstrous and misguided. But to torture for punishment and to create a reputation for fear is truly evil. More than that, it would fundamentally undermine any shred of moral authority this country has and it does matter.
I totally get where these Trump supporters come from. Many of them are younger and don't get it. And after 9/11 I, like many Americans was very angry and didn't give a fuck about the niceties of moral authority.
They just need to come around and see, sooner rather than later, truly how you fight matters because the conduct of the campaign sticks with you. This country is STILL trying to scrub the stain of Iraq off, and it'll be years before that's done - and I supported that war until the end of it. This isn't even about the terrorists. It's about the cost of doing business. Fundamentally, is what the US is investing in the campaign worth the outcome? At what point does not become worth it. I'd say at the very least, at the point at which we start utterly betraying ourselves for sake of expediency. At that point, we should find another way.
Just imagine if we made a Time machine and could go back to 2003 and would tell the country "if you launch the Iraq War, you'll spend a couple trillion dollars, lose 4500 troops, weaken your country against conventional powers, and gain a reputation for torture and war crimes that will take years to repair...oh and by the way on the other end of it, a terrorist-rapist army will conquer 1/3rd the country and Iraq will be failed state... will you do it?" Somehow, I strongly doubt it.
Again, terrorism needs to be treated as the 2.5 out of 10 problem it is, not the 9 out of 10 problem we sometimes get so worked up that we treat it as, just so we can make ourselves feel better. The United States is stronger today than it was a few years ago, in large part because Europe, Russia and China have hit terrible difficulties. But that's luck, and no where near as strong as we would be if we waged our post-9/11 era with a hell of a lot more wisdom and patience than we exhibited. We basically did everything wrong, and that's from someone who was ready to nuke Afghanistan into oblivion just to send a message, 15 years ago.