Tanaan or Timeless Isle?

[Deleted]

I like both, but if I had to pick, timeless it would be. The reason why, is it felt more dangerous. The mobs was harder to kill, players could go hostile to get bloody coins, not to forget the mini bosses in the middle.
Visually I prefers tanaan- I was never intro the panda \ Asian style, however it was a good expansion

[Leih]

Both weren't especially great, but Tanaan was the less frustrating of the two.

I hated Timeless Isle. It had some positive ideas but the execution was pretty meh.... and the fucking rares. Ugh. I've seen people in this thread say the rares were fun... Yuck. Running back and forth between spawn points every 20-40 minutes for months on end was really not fun.

Sure, I spent plenty of time on TI trying to get what I needed... but it wasn't what I'd call fun.

[Muxtar]

Haven't been playing any of them. I'd say Quel'Danas for no.1.

[ItachiZaku]

Timeless isle by a lot. I rarely bother going to Tanaan. Once in awhile, if i need some oil.

[Granyala]

Imho both are rather dull.
But at least in Tanaan you can fly. So Tanaan wins for me.

[Mahmeya]

How can you say that?

I say that only with regards to daily content, and I completely stand with that - whether or not people agree with my opinion is not important.
But it case of larger areas (Everbloom, Shattrath, Throne of KJ) it gives you a choice how to complete it.
It's not the best - I already mentioned Molten front is the best imo.
But it beats 5.0 gated grind.
It beats late phases of Isle of Thunder - which was like "do one quest in each subzone" and felt really weird ("hit and run") despite the story being decent.

[Zandro]

Both were terrible. Domination Point and Isle of Thunder were the best

This. But if I had to choose one, I would choose Timeless. More PvP was lots of fun.

[Denkou]

Haven't been playing any of them. I'd say Quel'Danas for no.1.

Ah, now there was some excellent WPVP to be found on IQD

[Lady Dragonheart]

*Shrugs* It's a tie for me, I liked them both for very different reasons.

[Darkeon]

I got bored of Timeless Island faster than I got of Tanaan Jungle.

However, don't get me wrong, I feel they are both bad when compared to previous expansions' "Islands".

[Granyala]

Ah, now there was some excellent WPVP to be found on IQD

Oooh yes.
I still remember that gankfest from my days on a RP-PvP server... :X

[Rudkobing]

Timeless Isle had its epic moments when everybody was killing the rares or Huolon while Tanaan had more daily quests, and you could fly there. I like them both.

[FeralSynapse]

Neither. Isle of Thunder.

[Daffan]

Tanaan is better. Timeless is complete garbage.

Either way, both are pretty bad.

[Raiju]

Ah, now there was some excellent WPVP to be found on IQD

Standing at max range killing people by guards who can't fight back?

[Tuesdays]

Idea, and size of Timeless, but the atmosphere of Tanaan.

Overall I liked TI more.

[Sierra85]

Haven't been playing any of them. I'd say Quel'Danas for no.1.

agreed. far superior experience overall.

[tsumeno]

Without flying Tanaan is not really fun... the treasure/rare daily for rep (needed for flying ) is super annoying!

For me, Timeless Isle.

[Polar1]

Tanaan has a better atmosphere as a zone. The color scheme of Timeless always made my eyes hurt like a bright disco ball.

Exactly because of the colors, I'll go with timeless isle. I have no patience for green and goo.

[Splenda]

I have had infinitely more fun in timeless isle, even when I go back to finish achievements, than I ever have in Tanaan.