@Reticence, when you get an appeal, does it come in a form similar to the following:
Appeal Valyrian's Lynch:
Appealer: "Valyrian is totally not scum, don't lynch him, yo."
TPR: "Valyrian might be scum. Lynch him, yo."
Basically, do you get clear indications on which source said what? Is it clear and unambiguous that two players provided replies, one from the appealer and one from the TPR?
- - - Updated - - -
I'm going to restart my 2-teams theory.
Uggor's team:
Uggor, Virothe*
Largehorn's team:
Largehorn, Dupti**
* Virothe was probably on Uggor's team. This depends on his Appeals Committee ability actually works. There are two possibilities in my mind: 1) He could initiate an appeal, in which case Virothe is on Uggor's team (since Dupti's team definitely has the same role). 2) He could provide input on an appeal (similar to what Ret said Senna and Arlee did), in which case he could be on either team.
** Dupti is most likely not on Uggor's team. This is based on Uggor's gambit, which would not make sense if they're both scum buddies on the same team. Admittedly it is possible they could be on the same team even with the gambit, but it's an unconventionally weird play in that context.
Players NOT on the same team:
- Uggor and Largehorn. They had the same ability.
- Dupti and Graeham. Gone after each other aggressively.
- Dupti and Kurenai. Gone after each other aggressively.
Players possibly not on the same team:
- Uggor and Kryllian. Kryllian provided a weak (non-aggressive) position 3 vote on Uggor's train D4, and a stronger (very aggressive) position 3 vote on Uggor D6.
- Uggor and Xanjori. Xanjori started up Uggor's train D5 and jumped on the train late (6/8) D6.
- Uggor and Robo. Robo was early on Uggor's train two consecutive days prior to his lynch. It was not a strong push though.
- Uggor and Celtic. Celtic was the second person on Uggor's train the day he was lynched. It could have been busing on a doomed ally though.
- Dupti and Celtic. Dupti claiming he protected Celtic N1 likely means he actually tried to kill Celtic N1 (since a kill was missing and Celtic is the person I targeted that night).
Players possibly on the same team:
- Uggor and Kurenai. Kurenai seemed too willing to believe Uggor's conviction against Dupti. This could be because of his bias against Dupti.
With this information considered, I'll amend the possible scum teams:
Uggor's team:
Uggor, Kurenai, (Virothe** or unknown*), (Graeham** or unknown*)
Largehorn's team:
Largehorn, Dupti, (Virothe** or unknown*), unknown*
* Unknown, in all four cases, could be any of Xanjori, Robo, Celtic or Kryllian. At the moment, I am not sure I can narrow any of them down further.
** If Graeham is scum, if he and Virothe have the same role card, they're not on the same team. If they don't have the same role card, they might be on the same team.
The logical consequence of this updated list is, unfortunately, that between Graeham, Xanjori, Robo, Celtic and Kryllian, 3 are scum and 2 are not, but I currently have no way to narrow this down further.
One thing I can potentially do to narrow this down is to point out that Celtic is probably not scum for 3 reasons: 1) His soft claim D1 probably lead to a missing NK, which was in town's favor. 2) Dupti's claim he protected Celtic likely means he actually targeted Celtic for a kill, which (weakly) removes him from being on Dupti's team. 3) His aggression against Uggor D6 helped to insure Uggor's lynch. Considering the push I made prior to that, it's possible he bussed a doomed ally though.