But those 10 years will most likely be rife with medical bills, doctors visits, medication, etc... which just hikes insurance rates up higher because the people getting treated may not even HAVE insurance. Don't the statistics show that the largest population of smokers are low income? The same group of people that are finding it more and more difficult to afford insurance and therefore choose to forgo the premium and go with the government fine instead? Yeah...
Stop defending smoking, we all know it's a terrible, unhealthy habit, it says so on the fucking label of every box of cigarettes that's purchased. I agree that it's your right to choose to do it if you want to, and I respect and will defend your right to make that choice, that doesn't make the decision any less bad.
Yeah, I can only speak from a US perspective. We don't have universal health care paid for by taxes here. Would be awesome if that were the case for this specific reason (has it's upsides and downsides) the people choosing to smoke would pay so many extra taxes that they are essentially covering their own medical costs. That's currently not the case as health care is still privatized.
We should ban cars that can travel faster than 80mph in the USA.
Anyone who argues that the reason we shouldn't sin tax something because the population buying them is poor should be disqualified from being a candidate, not that taxing those things in general is something we should advocate. The entire point of that tax is because people are too poor to afford it after the tax, which generally hasn't served as a deterrent, at best it serves to pay the social costs that the goods incur.
The entire concept of banning self destructive things is silly as well. Are you going to tell armed cops to shoot me if I refuse to put down the cigarette? Now we're not going to include putting a tent over a baby's crib and exhaling the smoke into it, or any of hypotheticals that people like to use in these cases, but its completely contradictory to use force to regulate what basically is a self-destructive behavior.
It should be a crime to smoke near other people, your pets or kids. And should count as animal/kid abuse.