Originally Posted by
Leadros
in my opinion, the current tanking in legion seems fine, but i only played DH tank, since he feels very close to WoD prot warrior.
a bad tank shouldnt be able to do dmg and will die a lot.
a good tank will not die alot, and will do medium dmg.
the best tanks however, can do alot of dmg and survive.
thats how it should be, atleast in my opinion, because how else do you reward good gameplay from tanks ? i really cant agree with the point of "having no control" if i take your example of going afk at a boss and having the same impact as not going afk. i can be a tank who does 50k dps or a tank that does 90K dps. And at the same time i have to watch out that i dont get killed or kill my group and max out my survivability.
i mean if you are happy that you can just stand afk and still survive, thats fine and good for you, but that doesnt mean that tanking has no depth attached to it. because its all about pushing the limits while staying alive.