[GAME] Rate The Character /10! NOMINEE Day #38: Magatha Grimtotem

[Deleted]

Rules:

- One random character to be polled every day, by rolling the dice. There is no predetermined list of names, so ANY character in the Warcraft universe could appear at any given day.
- Characters need 5 nominations to make it to the next poll. Meaning, any given character to get 5 unique nominations will be due the next day instead of picking a random character.
- If a character has two incarnations, both from the main and alternative universes, then the poll will be referring to both versions simultaneously.
- Every ten days, we will have a major character up, instead of a random! This will serve the purpose of giving you guys something to look forward to for sticking around. Meaning, Days #10,20,30... etc will be guaranteed to have a big name showing. This doesn't mean they won't appear in random days though, nor that you should stop nominating them if you want to see them sooner.

Nominations Rules Update - 29/5/2016

* Players are now limited to only one nomination per topic per user. You can still nominate a new character every single day once if you want.
* Any nominated character that remains at 1/5 nomination for five days will be dropped off the nominations list. Everyday, a character with a 1/5 nomination will receive an exclamation mark (!). Once a character receives five marks, they will be dropped.

Today's Character: Magatha Grimtotem

http://wow.gamepedia.com/Magatha_Grimtotem



Have fun voting, everyone! And don't forget to place your nominations as well!




Ranking:

Day #34: Khadgar - 8.77/10 (80 votes)
Day #10: Arthas Menethil - 8.71/10 (52 votes)
Day #21: Gul'dan - 8.65/10 (57 votes)
Day#33: Medivh - 8.48/10 (56 votes)
Day #06: Varok Saurfang - 8.11/10 (37 votes)
Day #07: Daval Prestor - 8.05/10 (20 votes)
Day #35: Lei Shen - 8.01/10 (67 votes)
Day #17: Cairne Bloodhoof - 7.98/10 (42 votes)
Day #01: Anduin Lothar - 7.90/10 (31 votes)
Day #20: Illidan Stormrage - 7.77/10 (63 votes)
Day #23: Ner'zhul - 7.76/10 (59 votes)
Day #26: Kel'Thuzad - 7.75/10 (62 votes)
Day #28: Anub'arak - 7.64/10 (50 votes)
Day #37: Kael'thas Sunstrider - 7.55/10 (66 votes)
Day #32: Rexxar - 7.4/10 (63 votes)
Day #25: Bolvar Fordragon - 7.34/10 (61 votes)
Day #36: Varian Wrynn - 7.05/10 (67 votes)
Day #08: Fandral Staghelm - 7.04/10 (23 votes)
Day #16: Chen Stormstout - 6.92/10 (39 votes)
Day #04: Cho'gall - 6.88/10 (34 votes)
Day #27: Sylvanas Windrunner 6.74/10 (93 votes)
Day #13: Wrathion - 6.68/10 (40 votes)
Day #30: Azshara - 6.32/10 (75 votes)
Day #05: Liadrin - 6.64/10 (36 votes)
Day #19: Rokhan - 6.15/10 (38 votes)
Day #03: Maiev Shadowsong - 6.09/10 (33 votes)
Day #22: Jaina Proudmoore - 6.04/10 (66 votes)
Day #14: Johnny Awesome - 6.03/10 (37 votes)
Day #12: Genn Greymane - 6.02/10 (54 votes)
Day #11: Baine Bloodhoof - 6/10 (43 votes)
Day #31: Shandris Feathermoon - 5.86/10 (57 votes)
Day #15: Garona Halforcen - 5.8/10 (25 votes)
Day #00: Kalecgos - 5.74/10 (31 votes)
Day #18: Alleria Windrunner - 5.73/10 (40 votes)
Day #29: Vol'jin - 5.4/10 (82 votes)
Day #02: Velen - 5.39/10 (23 votes)
Day #09: Lilian Voss - 4.64/10 (33 votes)
Day #24: Med'an - 2.37/10 (70 votes)



Nominations:

Qualified to Day #39: Archimonde - 5/5 (Zanjin, Kalecgos the Spellweaver, Zandro, Friendlyimmolation, Xiu the Timewanderer)
Qualified to Day #41: Nathanos Blightcaller - 5/5 (Friendlyimmolation, Captain Douchebag, Kalec, TheramoreIsTheBomb, Enthralled)
Qualified to Day #42: Lor'themar Theron - 5/5 (Lycanhero, Zulkhan, Enthralled, Arafal123, Friendlyimmolation)
Qualified to Day #43: Malfurion Stormrage - 5/5 (Snowraven, Enthralled, DemonHunter18, Arafal123, Lycanhero)
Qualified to Day #44: Moira Thaurissan - 5/5 (Melsiren, Xiu the Timewanderer, Kalecgos the Spellweaver, Enthralled, Lemonpartyfan)
Qualified to Day #45: Zul'jin - 5/5 (DarklingThrush. Terongor, Narathiel, Zulkhan , My User Name)
Qualified to Day #46: Tyrande Whisperwind - 5/5 (Snowraven, DemonHunter18, Enthralled, Roudene, Arafal123)
Qualified to Day #47: Alextrasza - 5/5 (ReVnx, Azirra, Enthralled, DemonHunter18, Lemonpartyfan)
Qualified to Day #48: Daelin Proudmoore - 5/5 (Graden, Kalecgos the Spellweaver, Littlepwny, Snowraven, DemonHunter18)
Qualified to Day #49: Elune - 5/5 (Sinraye, Snowraven, DemonHunter18, Zulkhan, Enthralled)
Qualified to Day #51: Yogg-Saron - 5/5 (Snowraven, Crawclaw, Lemonpartyfan, Lycanhero, Thrif)
Qualified to Day #52: Garrosh Hellscream - 5/5 (Melsiren, Enthralled, Soulwind, littleman40, True Horde)
Qualified to Day #53: Orgrim Doomhammer - 5/5 (Soulwind, Crawclaw, Zulkhan, Arrashi, Rathbourne)
Qualified to Day #54: Magni Bronzebeard - 5/5 (Humbugged, Snowraven, Kalecgos the Spellweaver, Iconja, Xiu the Timewanderer)
Qualified to Day #55: Vereesa Windrunner - 5/5 (Zulkhan, Melsiren, Enthralled, DemonHunter18, Amaterasu65)
Qualified to Day #56: Vashj - 5/5 (Sinraye, Snowraven, Enthralled, Crawclaw, devven9)
Qualified to Day #57: Millhouse Manastorm - 5/5 (BAMyouhaveaids, Lemonpartyfan, Smallfruitbat, Captain Douchebag)
Qualified to Day #58: Moroes - 5/5 (Raiju, Smallfruitbat, Xiu the Timewanderer, devven9, Lemonpartyfan)
Qualified to Day #59: Tirion Fordring - 5/5 (TheramoreIsTheBomb, Zulkhan, Melsiren, Project 501D13R, Arafal123)
Qualified to Day #61: Yrel - 5/5 (Snowraven, Soulwind, Flurryfang, Smallfruitbat, Xiu the Timewanderer)
Qualified to Day #62: Maraad - 5/5 (DarklingThrush, Snowraven, Kelthos, Rathbourne, DemonHunter18)
Qualified to Day #63: Uther - 5/5 (McNeil, Snowraven, Lemonpartyfan, Soulwind, Xiu the Timewanderer)
Qualified to Day #64: Sinestra - 5/5 (OIS, Kalecgos the Spellweaver, Crawclaw, DemonHunter18, Mari of Myth)
Kil'Jaeden - 4/5 (Friendlyimmolation, littleman40, Rathbourne, DemonHunter18)
Darius Crowley - 4/5 (Flurryfang, Warcrafting, Xiu the Timewanderer, Enthralled)
Sally Whitemane - 4/5 (Zanjin, Sinraye, Snowraven, McNeil)
Ysera - 4/5 (Sinraye, Snowraven, Smallfruitbat, TheMineKnight)
Muradin Bronzebeard - 4/5 (Enthralled, Sinraye, Snowraven, Smallfruitbat)
Brann Bronzebeard - 4/5 (Soulwind, IgnisVenom, Arafal123, DarklingThrush)
Sargeras - 3/5 (jasontheking1234, Rathbourne, Soulwind)
Falstad Wildhammer - 3/5 (devven9, Snowraven, IgnisVenom)
Teron Gorefiend - 3/5 (Terongor, Lemonpartyfan, Enthralled)
Mal'Ganis - 3/5 (Sinraye, Snowraven, Crawclaw)
Malygos - 3/5 (Enthralled, devven9, Crawclaw)
Taretha Foxton - 3/5 (Friendlyimmolation, Greenpro, Snowraven)
Valeera Sanguinar - 3/5 (Roudene, Sinraye, TheMineKnight)
Jastor Gallywix - 3/5 (TheCount, BAMyouhaveaids, Crawclaw)
Neptulon - 3/5 (Lycanhero, Roudene, Flurryfang)
Rivendare - 2/5 (Gib Lover, Kalecgos the Spellweaver)
Putress - 2/5 (Friendlyimmolation, Roudene)
Thassarian - 2/5 (DarklingThrush, Roudene)
Cenarius - 2/5 (Snowraven, Roudene)
Halduron Brightwing - 2/5 (Lycanhero, Sinraye)
Darion Mograine - 2/5 (Sinraye, Arafal123)
Jarod Shadowong - 2/5 (Lycanhero, Sinraye)
Rhonin - 1/5 (Enthralled) !!!
Phaoris - 1/5 (Roudene) !!!
Katrana Prestor - 1/5 (Lemonpartyfan) !!
Budd Nedreck - 1/5 (Arrashi) !
Gruul - 1/5 (Roudene) !
Edwin VanCleef - 1/5 (Melsiren) !

[Xiu the Timewanderer]

i think this is the first character i nominate

i like her role in the story overall but she isn't around much to care on the other hand so i will just give her a 7.

i nominate... Kalec's former boss Maly!

[Smallfruitbat]

7 for the sneaky cow. Minor character with a big impact -loved her intervention in the Mak'gora -nice little plot twist.

Rescuing Knaaks favourite from the axe -I nominate the red-haired wonder himself Rhonin!

[Deleted]

7/10 for me. I REALLY like her, and her role in the story when she is present, but the problem to me is that her appearances are too stretched and far between...

Loved that quest chain in Thousand Needles during Cataclysm a lot. I have this gut feeling that someday we will meet her again as she promised us in the end of it, as a raid boss. I don't think the Grimtotems can carry a raid, but in an expansion about Azshara, Old Gods, etc.. Maybe she can be in a minor raid of two or three bosses (Think the Gruul's Lair or Obsidian Sanctum type of raid.)

[Smallfruitbat]

Please gods, no! I don't want to see her as a raid boss. She wasn't overpowered, I never got the feeling it wouldn't take a bunch of us to take her out. I like these little troublesome factions existing, they make life interesting.

[Deleted]

Um... of course she would be riding a robot when we fight her.

Seriously, @Smallfruitbat, get real tbh mehn.

[Smallfruitbat]

I'll only accept it if the robot drops as a mount.

[Enthralled]

7/10
Would be higher if not for the fact that she's been MIA since Cataclysm. But what a sneaky, nasty bovine villain she is! Squatting in Thunder Bluff during classic, taking advantage of Cairne's good graces, pretending to be the leader of the "good" Grimtotem" -- the when the time was right, striking like a coiled serpent!

As always, great image there. I love those ICC shaman shoulders that the artist has depicted her with.

I nominate Brann Bronzebeard.

[Deleted]

@Smallfruitbat *rolls eyes* fine ok whatever you can ride Magatha.
@Enthralled so basically my thoughts exactly.

[Deleted]

-1 point for Cataclysm chain in which I had to rescue her, -1 for missed opportunities (I mean, she's not forgotten because her level is updated every xpack and that could mean Blizzard has some big plans for her but she could have been made a boss several times already or at least be involved in some events)

8/10

I'll be good today and let Kil'Jaeden qualify.

[devven9]

Gave her a 7. I honestly have no strong feelings one way or another about her but enjoyed the bits where she was relevant.

Let's bump Ysera up to 5/5

[Deleted]

Literally only one notable tauren not polled after this!

- - - Updated - - -

Bump for the Grimtotem!

[OIS]

While I hate her for arranging Cairne's death, WoW needs more conniving bitches like her. I think it's a cool fact that not all tauren are nature loving pacifists. Bonus point for Garrosh's letter. 7/10

Also, I've always liked her greeting: "What brings you to old Magatha?

Looks like Sinestra has made it. By the way, if people nominate Onyxia, would their votes be added seperately or included in Katrana Prestor? I don't know if this has been adressed before.

[Deleted]

While I hate her for arranging Cairne's death, WoW needs more conniving bitches like her. I think it's a cool fact that not all tauren are nature loving pacifists. Bonus point for Garrosh's letter. 7/10

Also, I've always liked her greeting: "What brings you to old Magatha?

Looks like Sinestra has made it. By the way, if people nominate Onyxia, would their votes be added seperately or included in Katrana Prestor? I don't know if this has been adressed before.

Katarana is Onyxia. We already had Deathwing under Daval Prestor.

[Combatbutler]

She gave tauren political conflict and represented a darker side of her kin, which was rather refreshing 7/10

I nominate Kil'Jaeden

[Deleted]

She gave tauren political conflict and represented a darker side of her kin, which was rather refreshing 7/10

I nominate Kil'Jaeden

Already qualified. Same for Ysera. Care to change your nomination?

[Combatbutler]

Already qualified. Same for Ysera. Care to change your nomination?

Malygos it is then

[Mari of Myth]

7/10. I'm hoping we will see her again and have the pleasure of being reintroduced to her story in the future.

Malygos, please!

[Melsiren]

8/10 as stated before in one of these posts she is one of my favorite female characters.

Grimtotem in general are the only tribe of Tauren I like... Magatha showing a side of their race that I find interesting.

[Deleted]

Malygos it is then

Ha!

Trivia Time:

- We have all the Aspects and former Aspects qualified at this point, except of Nozdormu who didn't even receive a single nomination yet.
- Magatha was the first nomination ever in this game.

- - - Updated - - -

7/10. I'm hoping we will see her again and have the pleasure of being reintroduced to her story in the future.

Malygos, please!

Malygos already qualified. Wanna change?