Originally Posted by
Osmeric
For every person reported, they look at what he said publically over a time interval (say, ten minutes) before the reports. They look for anything that could be objectionable.
They classify this three ways: (1) objectionable, which upholds the new penalty, (2) questionable, which does not uphold the penalty, but doesn't affect the reporters, and (3) innocent, which does not uphold the penalty, and in addition gives each reporter a black mark.
If a reporter gets enough black marks they are investigated in greater depth. If a group of reporters are getting black marks together that flags them for extra priority attention.