1. #20681
    Bloodsail Admiral Plehnard's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,101
    Quote Originally Posted by Tackhisis View Post
    Meanwhile, the Suicide Squad overtakes Warcraft in USA and Worldwide except China on its second day. Despite its abysmal reviews. That proves Warcraft failed because it was too niche and over-relied on CGI over colorful characters and convincing play.
    It proves that Universals advertising was just abysmal in comparison. Suicide squad had an amazing ad- campaign, a lot like deadpool.

  2. #20682
    Quote Originally Posted by Tackhisis View Post
    Meanwhile, the Suicide Squad overtakes Warcraft in USA and Worldwide except China on its second day. Despite its abysmal reviews. That proves Warcraft failed because it was too niche and over-relied on CGI over colorful characters and convincing play.
    Or maybe because people are into DC movies? Like... they got a huge fanbase. Most of those who went and watched Suicide Squad are fans you know. I mean, that is what you keep saying about the audience who went and saw Warcraft, so its good to be that case, right?

    A shame this didn't happen to Warcraft though... that people actually ignored the bad reviews. I guess DC fans aren't that smart, right?
    Last edited by Tornwar; 2016-08-07 at 11:21 PM.

  3. #20683
    Bloodsail Admiral Plehnard's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,101
    Quote Originally Posted by Tornwar View Post
    Or maybe because people are into DC movies? Like... they got a huge fanbase. Most of those who went and watched Suicide Squad are fans you know. I mean, that is what you keep saying about the audience who went and saw Warcraft, so its good to be that case, right?

    A shame this didn't happen to Warcraft though... that people actually ignored the bad reviews. I guess DC fans aren't that smart, right?
    Suicide Squad is one of the lesser known comics of DC, it opening near the same as Batman vs Superman is most likely due to the marketing and not to a giant fan base.

  4. #20684
    Deleted
    Quote Originally Posted by Plehnard View Post
    Suicide Squad is one of the lesser known comics of DC, it opening near the same as Batman vs Superman is most likely due to the marketing and not to a giant fan base.
    Marketing of Warcraft movie was pathetic tbh. There was one trailer 3 months before release. Like someone said they've spent around 100 milions $ for advertising... I don't belive it. Marketing was really poor with this one and i would say Universal f...ed up.

  5. #20685
    Old God Kathranis's Avatar
    15+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Austin, Texas
    Posts
    10,122
    Quote Originally Posted by Tackhisis View Post
    Meanwhile, the Suicide Squad overtakes Warcraft in USA and Worldwide except China on its second day. Despite its abysmal reviews. That proves Warcraft failed because it was too niche and over-relied on CGI over colorful characters and convincing play.
    The big difference between Suicide Squad and Warcraft was marketing.

    Suicide Squad proves that you don't need to have a good movie, you just need a good trailer.

    Warcraft had shitty trailers.

    From what I can gather, Suicide Squad's marketing budget was probably close to triple its production budget.
    Last edited by Kathranis; 2016-08-08 at 07:47 AM.

  6. #20686
    I doubt you could have a good trailer for Warcraft given it is very visually bland. There is nothing catchy, nothing visually satisfying. They literally had to put deleted scenes in there just to find something to show. You can throw money in it, but they are not going to create a visual porn you simply don't have.
    SS trailer, however, is nothing but bland...

    Orcs and knights are not particularly interesting creatures, even in a fantasy genre. Punk-looking superheroes are entirely different business.

    Warcraft is a John Carter all over again: a solid franchise, but bland and unexciting visuals.

  7. #20687
    Deleted
    Visually bland? Please.

  8. #20688
    Bloodsail Admiral Plehnard's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,101
    Quote Originally Posted by drakus View Post
    Visually bland? Please.
    If you wear "the hate goggles"(tm) everything becomes grey and bland!

  9. #20689
    Finally watched it. I guess I can understand the low ratings, it's not really a movie made for the average movie goer. My only issues are:

    - Orgrim was ruined. Betraying his own clan, letting Gul'dan kill him?

    Where is the Orgrim that has Gul'dan begging for his life at his knees, after he killed the entire Shadow Council? They better bring him in Part 2 because this one was a cowardly weakling. The Orgrim of the novels would bash Gul'dan's brains out the moment he used Fel in a Mak'gora.

    - Lothar vs Blackhand was incredibly lame. They should've at least had a 10 second explanation which tells the viewer that Fel makes orcs completely mindless brutes, based simply on instinct. Would've made more sense, but the fight was still lame.

    That's about it. I liked Wrynn a lot, Garona wasn't bad at all and the film had some great small touches ( like Khadgar tearing up when Durotan has his hand on his neck, thinking he's gonna die ).

    My greatest questions for the sequel, if it happens, are:

    1. Who gets the Gul'dan kill? At this point Khadgar/Lothar/Orgrim/Garona all have good reasons to kill him.

    2. Who's going to be Warchief next?

    3. How will Lothar die?

    But really not a bad movie at all. I might be biased ( I grew up playing warcraft3/WoW ) but I'd give it an 8 and put it above BvS and Suicide Squad.

  10. #20690
    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    - Orgrim was ruined.
    I kind of wonder if there is some edict to downplay him. He was given almost no role in WoD and while he was the main character of the first warcraft game he didn't really do much in the movie. I felt bad for the actor because he seemed like a genuine fan.

  11. #20691
    Deleted
    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    - Lothar vs Blackhand was incredibly lame. They should've at least had a 10 second explanation which tells the viewer that Fel makes orcs completely mindless brutes, based simply on instinct. Would've made more sense, but the fight was still lame.
    It was meant to be a Sergio Leone type of duel and having that idea in context, it did worked very well.

  12. #20692
    Quote Originally Posted by Jotaux View Post
    I kind of wonder if there is some edict to downplay him. He was given almost no role in WoD and while he was the main character of the first warcraft game he didn't really do much in the movie. I felt bad for the actor because he seemed like a genuine fan.
    Dude Rob got me so hyped with the Blizzcon footage!

    Orgrim is probably my favourite orc in Warcraft and they turned him into NOTHING.

    The Orgrim of our real story:

    - Beat Blackhand 1v1
    - Took control of the Horde, killed the Shadow Council and made Gul'dan his bitch
    - Fooled the entire Alliance in the Second War and set fire to Quel'thalas
    - Would've conquered Lordaeron if he hadn't decided vengeance on Gul'dan is more important
    - Killed Lothar 1v1
    - Escaped the Undercity, Lordaeron's prison
    - Found his way back to the Orcs and started a goddamn rebellion that reunited the Horde

    And this one BETRAYS Durotan, gets him and Draka killed and watches idly as Gul'dan cheats his way through the Mak'gora and kills Durotan. The real Orgrim would've charged in the second magic was used.

    And why did they not use weapons in Mak'gora, anyway? Mak'gora is a duel to the death where you are allowed one weapon and no armor.

  13. #20693
    Quote Originally Posted by drakus View Post
    Visually bland? Please.
    It probably is if it's a camrip.

  14. #20694
    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    Where is the Orgrim that has Gul'dan begging for his life at his knees, after he killed the entire Shadow Council? They better bring him in Part 2 because this one was a cowardly weakling.
    Orgrim was acting against the corrupted Durotan, and not against his clan.
    Also, not going to happen: Gul'dan of the movie is not a frail warlock further weakened by coma; here he is a half-demon and easily one of the strongest orcs alive, getting stronger with each kill.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by drakus View Post
    Visually bland? Please.
    Please name just two visually stunning scenes lasting more than 30 seconds.

  15. #20695
    Khadgar shenanigans




  16. #20696
    Deleted
    Quote Originally Posted by Tauror View Post
    It was meant to be a Sergio Leone type of duel and having that idea in context, it did worked very well.
    I definitely get what Jones was aiming for in that scene, but the problem is that you shouldn't try to imitate the great geniuses of filmmaking if you are not near their skill level.

    Edit: I felt I should clarify that I got nothing against Jones, I have liked all his movies I have seen (all two of them), just saying he is no Sergio Leone.
    Last edited by mmoc29422b2d1a; 2016-08-08 at 09:32 PM.

  17. #20697
    Bloodsail Admiral Plehnard's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,101
    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    Dude Rob got me so hyped with the Blizzcon footage!

    Orgrim is probably my favourite orc in Warcraft and they turned him into NOTHING.

    The Orgrim of our real story:

    - Beat Blackhand 1v1
    - Took control of the Horde, killed the Shadow Council and made Gul'dan his bitch
    - Fooled the entire Alliance in the Second War and set fire to Quel'thalas
    - Would've conquered Lordaeron if he hadn't decided vengeance on Gul'dan is more important
    - Killed Lothar 1v1
    - Escaped the Undercity, Lordaeron's prison
    - Found his way back to the Orcs and started a goddamn rebellion that reunited the Horde

    And this one BETRAYS Durotan, gets him and Draka killed and watches idly as Gul'dan cheats his way through the Mak'gora and kills Durotan. The real Orgrim would've charged in the second magic was used.

    And why did they not use weapons in Mak'gora, anyway? Mak'gora is a duel to the death where you are allowed one weapon and no armor.
    Well look at your list form a non Orgim- Fan standpoint for a minute. He's too bloody powerful, typical Marry Sue material.
    An Übermensch doesn't really have room to grow character, the film version does.

  18. #20698
    Quote Originally Posted by Plehnard View Post
    Well look at your list form a non Orgim- Fan standpoint for a minute. He's too bloody powerful, typical Marry Sue material.
    An Übermensch doesn't really have room to grow character, the film version does.
    If anyone's a Mary Sue that's Thrall.

    I'm not asking for even half of that but they fucking neutered Orgrim.

  19. #20699
    Bloodsail Admiral Plehnard's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,101
    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    If anyone's a Mary Sue that's Thrall.
    Won't disagree on that.

    Quote Originally Posted by pateuvasiliu View Post
    I'm not asking for even half of that but they fucking neutered Orgrim.
    He was probably meant to shine in the sequel. This time we already had too many main characters for one movie.

  20. #20700
    Quote Originally Posted by Plehnard View Post
    Won't disagree on that.



    He was probably meant to shine in the sequel. This time we already had too many main characters for one movie.
    Rob says he becomes his own person and a leader by the end of the film in his promos. Didn't really feel like it. I expected him to become Warchief but... eh.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •