Wordup and I get our information from the same place, it's quite trustworthy. That said, I'm going to take a day here soon to catchup on anything that might have been lost in launch madness; stat weights may have updated slightly. That's why I provide the link
The BiS list assumes same ilvl - higher ilvl trinkets with more stats are probably going to do better.
Venge thread, I don't have those kind of answers.