If pugging for mythic runs, don't pug yourself with other guildies.

[BiggestNoob]

No tanks should not do the orb, it should be a ranged DPS, ideally someone who has a lot of mobility.

But pugs are terrible, news at 11.

[simonlvschal]

Wait what? First of all, yes the orb is supposed to be carried by the tank.

And seems like you just have some shitty guidies. Better leave that guild and join Arathor EU!

eh no. the orb isnt suppose to be kept by tank rolf... a dps must do that.. as a tank your busy enough handling the kicks and everything

[Segus1992]

And my guild does has to do what exactly? Is your reading comprehension bad? I went with OTHER guild run.

Actually your English is just atrocious.

[JemiS]

Why is everyone talking about 3 guildies and kicks in Mythics?

The vote-kick system is in LFG, PuGs just takes a single leader to kick someone.

Running with guidlies can be good or bad, but it doesn't increase the likelihood that you get kicked in a PuG.

[anon5123]

Wait what? First of all, yes the orb is supposed to be carried by the tank.

Huh? Every single time I've done that boss, it was either me, or a ranged doing the orb. Never seen the tank do it.

[kamuimac]

You can get knocked off the edge while trying to find the shadow, yes you can time to knock back then try to find the shadow but its inefficient. You don't need tank to dps shadow..tank can hold aggro at range just fine.

sure if tank is a bad tank - but you don want bad tank in your group dont you ? unless you are the tank who looks for carry.

[ItsTiddles]

Screw Kelthuzad players, they seems like a bunch of a holes.

Yes, because running with a group of 3 is the same as the whole realm. You'll experience it from every realm. I'm rarely rude to pugs, unless we tried to help them and they repeatedly did the same mistakes. Too bad we might not ever know the whole story.

When it's not my guild, I prefer to pug with guild groups. They generally seem more coordinated and things go smoother.

Everyone has their preferences, though.

[Rhoe]

Why is everyone talking about 3 guildies and kicks in Mythics?

The vote-kick system is in LFG, PuGs just takes a single leader to kick someone.

Running with guidlies can be good or bad, but it doesn't increase the likelihood that you get kicked in a PuG.

I'm amazed it took until page 3 for someone to say this. And I very much agree. The only bad things with running with people who are guilded with each other and not with you is that they will generally never kick their own guildies even if they repeatedly prove that they are unable/unwilling to do mechanics or go afk for ages. Ran a lot of hcs with my own guildies while pugging one person, and so far we've kicked exactly 0 of them.

[Insomlol]

Ive tanked it twice, done orbs both times..

You throw the light when the green comes, throw it at the add when the add comes, and dont put yourself in a spot where you get punted off the edge. There isnt really a right or wrong class to do the orb, its just whoever is confident in doing it.

[Algoma0]

Any caster dps with mobility, every melee or even tank can do the orb. It doesn't really matter since you can throw the orb. If the group assigned you to do it, whatever your role, you better make sure you do it though. If it wasn't clear that it was your job, maybe a little communication would have helped.
My guess is that both the guild and you didn't do a good job communicating. Seems like those 3 "guildies" weren't the only problem here.

[Flurryfang]

Huh? Every single time I've done that boss, it was either me, or a ranged doing the orb. Never seen the tank do it.

Seems like we have been rading with other different groups My tanks are normally quite "rushy" so they take the orb to make sure people don't fuck up.... Or that is atleast what 1 guy said to me as a reason why he took the orb

- - - Updated - - -

eh no. the orb isnt suppose to be kept by tank rolf... a dps must do that.. as a tank your busy enough handling the kicks and everything

Have yet to this day seen a tank being kicked off the platform, so it does not really seem like a problem Also, there is a danger of dps getting hit by the boss/adds if they see the shadow adds first.

- - - Updated - - -

No, tank is the worse to carry the orb.

You can get knocked off the edge while trying to find the shadow, yes you can time to knock back then try to find the shadow but its inefficient. You don't need tank to dps shadow..tank can hold aggro at range just fine.

Again, i am just saying it is and has been working well for my groups to have the tank take it But i have seen a dps get killed because they went ahead of the tank and got hit in the face by either Cordana or one of her shadows

[pmkaboo]

Wait what? First of all, yes the orb is supposed to be carried by the tank.

And seems like you just have some shitty guidies. Better leave that guild and join Arathor EU!

nope, having it on tank is a terrible idea.

[Flurryfang]

I would agree with trash, but for the boss. She does a knock-back and trying to run around searching for the adds makes it pretty damn easy to get knocked off the ledge, especially considering the adds pop up in the corners. It's much easier for a ranged DPS to handle the light.

You don't have to search for the adds, they give themself away, so not that much movement. I will agree, that it is best for a ranged dps to take it, but it is not every day that you have a not-stupid ranged dps And then its better to have tank around, since melee will lose a hell of dps by running around

[ceall]

Healers and sometimes ranged dps are a lot better on cordana light orbs (that's the topic here I guess), as the tank can stand still a lot more, which leads to more melee dps cuz of less moving around. Ranged classes are a lot more flexible for that duty.

[Holofernes]

Wait what? First of all, yes the orb is supposed to be carried by the tank.

And seems like you just have some shitty guidies. Better leave that guild and join Arathor EU!

light shouldnt be done on mythic by tank. tank gets stun / kick combo, thats defining your movement. throwing light, moving with light to adds, absorbing voidzones is very dangerous for tanks to get kicked from platform or into wall of death or to mess up returning glaive postioning, resulting in big fat dmg and debuff . its best done by healer or range dd. best bet is healer, as they have very little else to do in this fight.

[Flurryfang]

nope, having it on tank is a terrible idea.

Seems to be working my friend

[LiiLoSNK]

Skill issue.

[Deleted]

And my guild does has to do what exactly? Is your reading comprehension bad? I went with OTHER guild run.

Your writing skills could use some work instead. Nowhere did you clarify this. You just say: "don't play with guildies", which actually is easily interpreted as own guildies, since that's what we call them.

[pmkaboo]

Seems to be working my friend

running raids with 3 tanks also works

[Yizu]

Why would the resto druid or the range dps move into melee range of mobs to be able to kill them? makes no sense, and you only soak whats needed, running around soaking like mad dont help.

LOL you dont have to go melee range to find the add, u throw it on the add