Originally Posted by
Medium9
Relevant to your agenda, and there is a whole lot wrong with it. I'ts amazing how you make yourself believe you couldn't see this yourself.
While I don't condone ANY violence againts more or less random targets to merely get a message across, I do however somewhat understand where it comes from, and why it's on the rise. Imagine you were a little kid and some 120kg man stepped on your foot and won't move. At first, because you're brought up so well, you just ask for him to move a tad, please. If nothing happens, you may try it louder. After that you may knock him in the side slightly to get his attention. Then you'll start screaming for just about anybody to help you, and finally you almost have no other option left than to hurt the man, since all other attempts were futile, and your foot slowly turns into mush.
That kid is the political right in Germany for you, and the man is the general public. It's even a bit worse, because in the real world scenario, there's a few hundred thousand people urging the man to ignore you as best as he can. The ONLY thing you foster with this "shut-them-down" policy is to anger them. They believe what they believe, and being told to fucking shut up and preach another gospel won't suddenly enlighten anyone. Who would like to be told what to think and do?
The right should NOT be shut out, silenced, ignored and buried. These are proper citizens with, at the base of it, legitimate concerns, and all they want is to be heared and represented. If we would start to fetch them from where they actually are, and offered cooperation in trying to address some of the issues they deem important, no one would be pressured into being very very loud just to be recognized. But noooo, oh gooood! Germany CANNOT let ANYthing remotely rightish into it's substance, how DARE we?? This fairy tale simply ignores that EVERY country has their right wing, and in almost all other countries, they're at least recognized and can thus be far better regulated. Making them outlaws is preciesly how WE create right wing violence. But as a German, you're just simply not allowed to have this opinion.
I wouldn't consider myself neither left nor right, not even really center, but I strongly believe that a proper Democracy has the damn duty to let EVERYONE that can muster up relevant numbers have a voice and provide matters to soberly and thoroughly discuss within the public.
Sure, you'll always have a few total nutjobs that will still be violent no matter what, but these then really are just people that want to be violent, and usually care very little for their reasoning. They'll always find something to be violent for. The vast majority would very likely happily take part in the political process in a civilized manner.
And all I wrote here counts 1:1 just as well for the far left.
A small real-world example of some sorts might be our green party. In the beginning they were little more than a somewhat organized movement consisting of many small fragmented groups, some civilized, some commiting actual politically motivated crimes. And then, suddenly, they somehow managed to be heared, made a few lucky personnell choices that made them look a bit more proper than a left terrorism cell, and then they became an actual party. Look where they are now! A regular center-left party rose from them, still having many of the core values they began with, and are part of our normal daily political landscape. Sure, they lost many of their hard-liners along the way and these may continued towards Antifa and others and still need a political home, but actual left wing terrorism (which we had quite a bit of!) has almost died out ever since there was some sort of legitimated representational body for these people.
That something like this just isn't an option for right leaning people "because Germany", which makes those that feel muted by it very angry, is a thing I very well understand. Again: I'm not saying that they are right to be violent. At all! But one CAN reason for it.