Originally Posted by
mvallas
*Cracks Knuckles*
I get to explain this to another one! And it's Tony so it's bonus! ^_^
On a serious note Tony, I used to think exactly the same thing. When suddenly everybody had MLP Avatars popping up I said "Dafuq happened!? did every male have their balls drop off!?".
But, being the science-based minded person I am... Instead of passing my opinionated judgement for fact, I asked myself further "OK, lets find out WHY this is!"
Seeing it pop up on Netflix, I decided to try to figure this out myself and so I started watching the show.
Let me tell you, the first two episodes (a story about the 5 main ponies comming together to find the "Elements of Friendship" which come in the form of jewlery they wear) made me have the overwhelming desire to go outside and chop down a tree, wrestle an alligator and fight off a pack of ninjas to reassert my manhood! :P
HOWEVER! I decided to keep pushing on...
After that girlish 2-parter, the entire show diverts away from "girly" and anything we remember from the 80s cartoon and becomes a straight-up character study of the bizzare personalites of these characters and the world they live in. The writing goes MUCH more than some happy-go-lucky foo-foo show to a combination of action, sight-gags ala Looney Toons, all while maintaining a SENSIBLE level field of optimism (Unlike the pandering optimism of "girly" cartoons we both know of). It is far closer to "Powerpuff Girls" level of anime mockery than anything pretty-foo-foo that we remember.
These aren't just ponies giving gifts and being smiley-happy... these go crazy, get angry, have looney-toon level melt-downs, ect... Hell - in one season there was a straight-up FIGHT sequence of them fighting invading shadow creatures (and by "Fighting" I don't mean kooky things like Flower pots on heads... no, I mean straight-up punching and kicking!). ANd lets not forget there's lots of fun little nods all through the show that only adults would get (One scene having pony versions of the Dude, Walter and Donny from "The Big Lebowsky" come to mind, and a spaced out hippy pony named "Tree Hugger" who (if memory serves me) has a pot leaf for a mark on her.
EDIT: And I forgot guest stars... hell, they got Weird Al-Yankovich in and even did a polka-parody song in one episode, and John D Lancie basically reprises his role as "Q" from Star-Trek in the form of a character named "Discord" who is this omnipotent dragon who can just wish up crazy/bizzare insane things just to fuck with people and keep himself from being bored!
Now, I'm not saying you should watch it at all! (i'm smarter than to ask that! You'd probably still hate it. :P) but just wanted to clarify that the kind of show it is is NOT what you think it is, especially if like me you grew up near/around the 80s and remember the 80s cartoon. It's much closer to an old-school Looney-Tunes show than anything girlish. And, if anything, it's popular because there's NOTHING else like it on TV today. It is a pretty unique cartoon.
But since then I've been making it a point to explain it to adults who were just like me - completely baffled as to why a so-called "Girls cartoon" suddenly became popular with a generation of MEN of all things! I don't try to get them to watch or like it... but at least try to get them to understand that the show is NOT what they picture in their heads at all, and why many do like it.