Eugenia Cooney, is she being skinny shamed?

[Al Gorefiend]

She's still more attractive than someone overweight. Sounds like targeted jealousy bullying

[Halyon]

She's still more attractive than someone overweight. Sounds like targeted jealousy bullying

Yeah, anorexia is so attractive, innit...

There's no jealousy in telling a skeleton that they should consider eating a bit more healthily, or if they're allright. Her attractiveness doesn't mean shit if her health is at stake...

[Al Gorefiend]

Yeah, anorexia is so attractive, innit...

There's no jealousy in telling a skeleton that they should consider eating a bit more healthily, or if they're allright. Her attractiveness doesn't mean shit if her health is at stake...

Nah she's not a skeleton. Very pretty, I wish her fame and happiness.

[Halyon]

Nah she's not a skeleton. Very pretty, I wish her fame and happiness.

In a coffin? 'Cus that's what she'll get if she gets worse...

[Murderdoll]

Ive seen pictures of Jews walking out of Auschwitz with more meat on them.

She is clearly unwell and needs medical help.

[endersblade]

That isn't healthy in the least. She hardly has any muscle structure. I can imagine her bones are probably brittle too.

I wouldn't 'shame' her for being skinny - I'd shame her for thinking there's nothing wrong with herself.

[Karadros]

Nah she's not a skeleton. Very pretty, I wish her fame and happiness.

I've seen spiders with more bodyfat than that girl has. Clearly anorexic.

[Al Gorefiend]

In a coffin? 'Cus that's what she'll get if she gets worse...

She takes care of her hair, her makeup looks great, she has good fashion sense. She cares more of self-image and taking care of herself more than what many ham-faced women on the street do. She is pretty and has a unique body shape, no need to shame.

[daenerys]

A person shouldn't be shamed for being overweight or to skinny, but they should be aware of the health concerns, and not be told they are alright or healthy when they clearly are not. Being this skinny is far more unhealthy than being 200lbs overweight.

[Celista]

Nah she's not a skeleton. Very pretty, I wish her fame and happiness.

Are you for real? Watch her videos, she definitely has an eating disorder. I don't think this is a case of jealousy at all.

- - - Updated - - -

She takes care of her hair, her makeup looks great, she has good fashion sense. She cares more of self-image and taking care of herself more than what many ham-faced women on the street do. She is pretty and has a unique body shape, no need to shame.

Hmmmmmmmm....lol.

I agree that she has nice hair and makeup.

[Bapestar]

Well, anecdotal or not, I can personally prove you wrong. I know other people who can prove you wrong. I started, and am still sticking with my 3x workouts a week at a gym, despite social anxiety, because I have a trainer I can talk to, and who will never put me down. Because I put myself down enough already, and I do it over the smallest, stupidest shit, I'm extremely self-aware of my own short-comings. I know others who will tell you the same. a positive support-network makes such a difference for the better, shaming does not.

I know it does, but it's not required. Never said shaming was good either.

[Al Gorefiend]

Are you for real? Watch her videos, she definitely has an eating disorder. I don't think this is a case of jealousy at all.

That is for her doctor to determine. She's at a lower risk than where obesity puts people, our attention should be focused there. Not gang harassment of a girl who is happy and thinks she's pretty.

[Aeluron Lightsong]

Hmmmmmmmm....lol.

I agree that she has nice hair and makeup.

I barely notice, her very unhealthy weight(Underweight??) is too noticeable.

That is for her doctor to determine. She's at a lower risk than where obesity puts people, our attention should be focused there. Not gang harassment of a girl who is happy and thinks she's pretty.

Just because they feel ok doesn't mean they actually are. She's just as much at risk as obesity, it's just the other side of the weight spectrum.

[Celista]

A person shouldn't be shamed for being overweight or to skinny, but they should be aware of the health concerns, and not be told they are alright or healthy when they clearly are not. Being this skinny is far more unhealthy than being 200lbs overweight.

It's probably equivalent to being in the 900 lbs category. She's at the stage where it's getting life-threatening.

Not everyone knows this with anorexia but there does become a point where your body starts to cannibalize itself, that is typically the point of no return.

[Celista]

That is for her doctor to determine. She's at a lower risk than where obesity puts people, our attention should be focused there. Not gang harassment of a girl who is happy and thinks she's pretty.

You can tell just by looking at her that her BMI is in the dangerous category. I say this as a person who was medically supervised during high school for a short period of time because my weight got too low due to sports (track and cross-country).

I was never this thin which is telling as to how low her weight is, my lowest was 110 at 5'8.

[Al Gorefiend]

I barely notice, her very unhealthy weight(Underweight??) is too noticeable.






Just because they feel ok doesn't mean they actually are. She's just as much at risk as obesity, it's just the other side of the weight spectrum.

If the obese didn't set the bar so high in the other direction people wouldn't be so mortified by the concept of fat that they seek the other side of the spectrum. As for OP, that girl isn't to that point yet.

People see the obese waddling around and being such a burden on society that it terrifies them into not eating. In fact, I'm bold enough to say girls like Eugenia Cooney are victims of obesity.

- - - Updated - - -

You can tell just by looking at her that her BMI is in the dangerous category. I say this as a person who was medically supervised during high school for a short period of time because my weight got too low due to sports (track and cross-country).

I was never this thin which is telling as to how low her weight is, my lowest was 110 at 5'8.

People's bodies are built differently.

[The One Percent]

You can do what you want with your body. She looks fucking terrible, though.

[Celista]

People see the obese waddling around and being such a burden on society that it terrifies them into not eating. In fact, I'm bold enough to say girls like Eugenia Cooney are victims of obesity.

Nah. Remember Karen Carpenter? That was pre-obesity epidemic. Eating disorders have been around for quite some time.

[Halyon]

That is for her doctor to determine. She's at a lower risk than where obesity puts people, our attention should be focused there. Not gang harassment of a girl who is happy and thinks she's pretty.

No, it isn't. It's a different set of equally bad risks you get for being anorexic than you get for being obese.

I know it does, but it's not required. Never said shaming was good either.

Yes it very well can be required. It was for me. If I can't think myself out of my horribly negative way of thought, I need someone else to help me with it until I can. I'm on my way there, but it wouldn't have been possible w/o my trainers help.

[Aeluron Lightsong]

If the obese didn't set the bar so high in the other direction people wouldn't be so mortified by the concept of fat that they seek the other side of the spectrum. As for OP, that girl isn't to that point yet.

People see the obese waddling around and being such a burden on society that it terrifies them into not eating. In fact, I'm bold enough to say girls like Eugenia Cooney are victims of obesity.

There's no evidence to suggest obesity affects this girl. It's just massive supposition.

People's bodies are built differently.

Yes but there is a point where being that skinny is unhealthy.