How can you say that gear no longer matter though? With every ilvl above 800 you get a 0.1% increase, getting 855+ ilvl atm is not really hard. That's a 5.5% increase in stats.. If I had only been doing PvP, I would have like 810 ilvl tops at the moment. (No, I don't count pvp WQs as PvP..).
In addition, I would have a ton lower artifact power than everyone else..
That would put me at a disadvantage, and no matter how big or small that disadvantage is, IT SHOULD NOT EXIST..
The above is a made-up scenario, I enjoy PvE from time to time and am sitting at 851 ilvl and a decent amount of artifact power, but that is besides the point really. The point is, that I feel like I HAVE to do PvE in order to stay competitive in PvP. Knowing that you are in a disadvantage IS going to bother people.
Edit: With that said, I still agree with @
ShiyoKozuki and would be completely fine with gear not mattering at all in PvP, as well as giving you all the arti talents unlocked. The issue is that PvE rewards the best gear for PvP.. Only people who suck at PvP and love PvE can think that is a good idea.. I mean, go back to playing vanilla or s4 or whatever..