All the claims on this forum about how bad BMonks are, were NOT backed up by math and proper arguments in the first place. With "perception" and "feeling" - sure yeah. They are both an important part of gaming. But my perception and feeling can differ vastly. Now let's go down to your own "math" and "proper arguments".
"The fact that brew monks are PERCEIVED as bad/subpar." - key word "perception" - it's not a "fact" that BMonks ARE bad/subpar, nevermind how hard you try to make it sound logical. Not math nor proper argument. Also that perception is based on how many voices as opposed to how many silents? No clue, right?
"The fact that half of the allready few players who play brew are finding the spec not-fun." - this is NOT a fact. This is an assumption which lacks "math" completely. Show me numbers please and how you got them.
"The fact that monks are not played widely." - numbers please. I guess you COULD be right, but do you have them? How do they compare to other specs?
"But you haven't adressed why that still makes raidleaders accross the globe pick other tanks over brew tanks." - numbers please. Again you possibly COULD be right, but do you have them? There are raid tanks (7/7M) on this forum - BM players. Did you talk to them? Did you talk to their GMs?
"the main concences is that Monks are the worst tanks." - is that this "proper argument" you mentioned?
These are all your statements. Aside from these, I also found this one:
"I like totem for picking up the adds. PRoblem is that i still sometimes misjudge its range and accidently pull more than intended... " - so are you a l33t pwnz0r or still trying to get there?
You're talking all perception and expect others to change it for you and prove to you that your PERCEPTION is incorrect with arguments you don't value yourself (because you're not giving them in the first place - math for example or numbers)? That's the "mature stance"? Not in my world really.
- - - Updated - - -
"We would all benefit from a different attitude then the one you are displaying." Yes man. Very much so. Start with yourself
I ENJOY MY BMONK and apart from VERY MINOR stuff (i.e. Dave - come back, Dave!) I don't think they lack anything.