One good thing, one bad thing about legion.

[Lightbull]

I have to name one thing? Okay...

Good: Everything in Suramar. From the quests to the art style to the lore and the convenient teleporters, everything is top notch imo.

Bad: Artifact weapon system. It's a nice way to progress your character, but it's super grindy and annoying to catch up on alts. 7.1.5 might change my opinion on that though.

[wooootles]

GOOD - Mythic+

BAD - getting screwed by legendary drop rates

[ZakZak]

Good - Mythic+ dungeons (still haven't managed to clear anything with three affixes, so still plenty of challenge for my level of play).
Bad - RNG legendaries (I've been lucky myself, but have watched lots of friends get crappy ones they won't use).

I can't think of any way for them to have the number of legendaries they have AND have them always be a pleasant surprise (instead of a sore disappointment) whenever they drop. It would have made it feel grindy, but I'd rather the bosses just drop a legendary token you can use to buy whichever one you want the most. Either that or just give each spec one single kick ass legendary that everyone wants instead of a bunch of junk ones.

[OperationFerret]

Good: Professions. Collecting and upgrading recipes is fun even if the reward factor isn't always there.

Bad: Some world quests are annoying to complete like when you have to find that one unique mob hiding in a cave or above a cliff and there is no minimap icon to help you locate it.

[Hyperborean]

good: M+ and making friends through repeat content.

bad: legendaries and the way that they limit choice and 2ndary balance in spec.

[Daedius]

Good:

Plenty to do.

Bad:

Too much to do that just feeds the whole multi-layered RNG element to it.

[Sae]

Good:
Being able to log in and always have something to do that will further progress your character. Artifacts and AP are a great system. Kind of sucks that Artifact Knowledge doesn't apply to alts, but I suppose it's getting made easier soon so that's not a big deal.

Bad:
The entire gearing system; legendary RNG, titanforging, sockets, and the absurdity of some classes favoring 840 jewellery over 880 because secondaries are so widely varying in power levels.

[Banquetto]

Good : World Quests

Bad : Queueable 5-mans less relevant than ever

[Constraint]

Good thing: Suramar. Absolutely love the zone. It's leagues ahead of the other expac zones for mine, and took a fairly tiny expansion world and made it seem a lot bigger.

Bad thing: Legendaries. Only the most braindead of us didn't see them being a problem as soon as they were announced. But balancing classes around RNG drops, that are completely out of your control, with colossal power-swings attached to them is borderline asinine, and I'm still to understand how seasoned game designers could be so unfathomably stupid.

[ryanmahaffe]

Im going to do two
Because I am a rebel

Good:
World quests
Legendary system (been playing since legion launch, no legendary, still like the idea behind the system, quit bitching"

Bad:
Pvp incentives are bar-non
Keystones such imo, mythic plus is amazing but random keystones are meh imo


Overall amazing expansion

[Brewhan]

Reading comprehension

impossible to only put one good and one bad with legion.

[Frandaero]

Good: Awesome expansion all around

Bad: Legendaries RNG ruining the late game raiding fun for me

[Legiun]

good: artefact weapons and the talents are nice and enjoyable


bad: legendarys , i have 6 or 7 now but to be honest i think legendarys are the biggest crap they ever introduced into wow... and the spammable mythic +

your last quote is what is bad about wow today

[Lane]

Good: Class hall campaigns.

Bad: Too much RNG.

[Deleted]

Good:
-Class Hall campaigns and Artifact Weapons

Bad:
-A single questline for every zone plus non open areas. The areas are so densely crowded and disconnected from one another that feel like big dungeons. I was expecting a Nagrand style areas, big and open, with cliffs and plateaus to climb up to.
Only Suramar is well designed.

[Teri]

This coming from a player who came back after 3 year for Legion that's not raiding right now (raided 8 years in a row 2005-2013).

Good:
- World Quests + Titanforged keeping mid-range content & repeated gear drops more relevant.

Bad:
- Time gates for Artifact research especially on alts (hopefully mostly fixed after 7.1.5)
- If Artifact knowledge is "fixed" then I'd have to say Legendary RNG.

[Deleted]

Good: So much to do, I am a dirty casual as well so if don't want to do something, I don't. Groundbreaking, I know.

Bad: Hunters. Never been a big fan of hunters but used mine to do JC/Ench but it is just so bad now I really can't be bothered. BM might be the most boring spec ever, MM is a nightmare to work with and doesn't match the idea they built up in alpha at all and while survival is okay it just doesn't seem finished to me.

[Deleted]

Good: more stuff to do than wod
Bad: classes are boring when compared to what they used to be.

[Fatel]

Good: World quests and lots of ways to advance characters

Bad: Crafting system\ The death of pugs (couldnt decide which I hated more)

[Lazerbrain]

good - world quests (they should add world quests to old world zones too, let the legion invade everywhere.)

bad- mythic + keystone.