Originally Posted by
rda
Quest greens were scaling up as well, but the ilvl range was fairly big and so the difference was fairly big - topping at around 45% in the extreme case (all quest greens vs all conquest). Typical difference between quest greens and honor: ilvl 650 to ilvl 675 - that's a lot, about 26%. Typical difference between honor and conquest: ilvl 675 to ilvl 690 - that's about 15%, I took the season with the largest difference, other seasons were on the level of 9.5%. Difference between quest greens and conquest is, unsurprisingly, about 45%.
The point is this: comparing to quest greens serves no useful purpose. You graduated out of them very quickly. WoD had intermediate-level aspirant's gear, which would be in the example above scale to ilvl 660 - shaving half the distance to honor. Both aspirant's and honor gear was raining from the sky, it is no exaggeration to say that you could get full aspirant's / honor in a matter of two 2-hour evenings and get full honor with like two more evenings - and that's conservative. And when you were going into a BG, your opponents were not full conquest - even the best people were only getting their weapon and 4p in the end of the first month, that's about half-way through. And if we aren't talking about the first month, it all gets much better for the guy just starting out because of conquest catch-up - you were getting 3-4 pieces of conquest right in the first evening, and your rating didn't matter one bit because you were always landing at a place with 50/50 winrate.
And the kicker: if getting from quest greens to honor-level was so daunting (no matter that it takes several evenings), there was a completely trivial solution - just scale quest greens to the level of honor gear right out the bat. Takes two seconds to implement, delivers all the goodies Legion's system can ever hope to deliver to the players, alienates nobody. Win-win-win-win.
(And I am not even talking that the difference between a noob and a geared guy in Legion is not just, say, 7% from gear, it's also 15% from artifact and you don't start competing at all (it's like 30% or more, hard to measure, but very significant) before you get PVP talents. So, is there any improvement at all? I don't know...)