No. It was not. Have you even seen kill videos? Top raiders wouldn't make it in heroic today. Top tier raiders standing in void zones, forgetting to flask, out of consumables, keyboard turning, delayed casts/attacks, clicking everything but 1-5 and more.
Also, nobody raided 24/7 in vanilla.
World-first Ragnaros kill....clearly players were as skilled in 2005.
Something important that many do not understand today.. Back then DPS meters as a measure of performance were not a thing.
This was the case because first of all, resources were tight for all classes. Much like arcane plays today.
And second because threat was a thing. You could go as high as your tanks threat would allow you.
There was a hard roof for all classes and trying to dish out as much dmg as possible by being right below the tank in threat would probably cause your raid to wipe as bosses tended to be taunt-immune.
I think the point of the video was, that a world first player didn't even have slice&dice on his bars.
Math. Seriously start here: http://www.purplemath.com/. Once you reach about 6th grade, let me know and I can explain all of the concepts that would make it clear why even at 915 most guilds would be incapable of killing those bosses.
Hint: I said the exact same thing based on Helya progression, that it would be an underkilled boss and require nerfs because it's overtuned. My reasoning was EXACTLY the same, and it still remained fairly underkilled even with ~35->54 traits AND significant nerfs. The situation has shifted such that gear upgrades are much weaker by comparison to even that case, so as is fun to do with a room full of people who don't understand literally 6th grade math: there are at least 3 bosses in this instance that will require massive nerfs because they are actually unkillable for most guilds, regardless of their gear.
Last edited by BiggestNoob; 2017-02-05 at 12:58 PM.
I am sorry but the point you make is very misleading as you're trying to compare a WF today with a WF 12 years ago. Perhaps you did not play during those times so you cannot understand the context properly.
The so-called 'raid difficulty' and 'skill level' terms are all relative. Back in 2005, factors you today take for granted such as threat management, mana management, decent health pools for all players etc. were very different. Cloth classes had 2-3k health pools, threat was a constant problem (part of the reason Thunderfury was probably the best legendary ever), healers ran out of mana very quickly, add-ons were still at the beginning, flasks were practically never used as they disappeared on death, and so on and so forth. For the people in that video, Ragnaros was extremely hard and they were very proud to have killed him.
Guilds wiped for weeks to kill Ragnaros so it is very to assume that the raiders today are somewhat more skilful. However, "skill" does not grow on trees. The same players who played in 2005 might be playing in 2017 killing Gul'dan Mythic and they did NOT become "more skilful" as the game progressed. They were always skilful, but they adapted to the times accordingly.
That you are downplaying how hard vanilla or TBC was is a disservice to those who sweat blood and tears to kill those bosses. And it's not just about mechanics: the original Kel'Thuzad or Kael'Thas were complex bosses as well.
thats what they said last week. since then we got what, 7 kills? And guilds got videos to know what works. the guilds that are like sub 5% will get a kill, but majority of 7/10 guilds arent that close, I dont think we will get more than 25-30 guilds with 8/10 after next reset
when does serenity and method start raiding today?
www.twitch.tv/xchrispottertvx
Officer in the World First Guild Method.
We are recruiting any exceptional players who want to play at a World first level.
www.method.gg
Currently playing healer (Resto Druid main).
That's not true, i was a little noob back then, but even i knew you should bind your abilites because i played a lot of RPGs. I didn't have as many binds as i would eventually in like WotLK and still clicked 3+ minute long cds and mounts, but i knew that's important to have your kick on F, etc.