Originally Posted by
EzG
No. In 99% of all cases drape of shame is going to be better with current gear. I'm currently trying to find that 1% but I don't think anyone is literally gonna be lucky enough to reach that point, more math needed.
This is some rough fucking shitty napkin math i did early on when i got the cloak. i'm ignoring artifact % and all kinds of shit like IoL. I know i didn't have to math out X casts. But i looked at a couple of logs and took average casts. This is nearly 100mil healing. If you look at augur/elisande logs we are 250mil up to 350mil per fight so the difference is also going to be bigger. I'm sure there are some mistakes in there. I took very round numbers etc. Rounded up heavily on the second set on the per cast heal and amount of crits. 0.65 crit% isn't actually going to add a lot of crit casts. I also checked individual casts with more precision and artifact bonus etc and that showed a bigger gap. But unfortunately i never saved that stuff.
But hopefully the math is "helpful"
a 925 tich cloak would give
738 Intellect
262 Critical Strike
-27 vers
versus the drape of shame.
so lets say
50000 int
45% crit
10% vers
Code:
50 shocks 400% * 50000 = 200,000 * 1.1 = 220,000
220,000 * 5 = 1,100,000
220,000 * 45 = 9,900,000 * 2.1 = 20,790,000
21,890,000 total
50 FoL 450% * 50000 = 225,000 * 1.1 = 247,500
247,500 * 28 = 6,930,000
247,500 * 22 = 5,445,000 * 2.1 = 11,434,500
18,364,500 total
40 HL 425% * 50000 = 212,500 * 1.1 = 233,750
233,750 * 22 = 5,142,500
233,750 * 18 = 4,207,500 * 2.1 = 8,835,750
13,978,250 total
120 LoD Hits 180% * 50000 = 90,000 * 1.1 = 99,000
99,000 * 66 = 6,534,000
99,000 * 54 = 5,346,000 * 2.1 = 11,226,600
17,760,600 total
1000 JoL Hits 20% * 50000 = 10,000 * 1.1 = 11,000
11,000 * 550 = 6,050,000
11,000 * 450 = 4,950,000 * 2.1 = 10,395,000
16,445,000 total
70 Tyr's Hits 150% * 50000 = 75,000 * 1.1 = 82,500
82,500 * 39 = 3,217,500
82,500 * 31 = 2,557,500 * 2.1 = 5,370,750
8,588,250 total
Grand total of 97,026,600 healing
Versus
50738 int
45.65% crit
9,95% vers
ROUNDING UP hard on crit casts and healing per cast
Code:
50 shocks 400% * 50738 = 202,952 * 1.0995 = 223,146
223,146 * 4 = 892,584
223,146 * 46 = 10,265,716 * 2 = 20,529,432
21,422,016 total
50 FoL 450% * 50738 = 228,321 * 1.0995 = 251.039
251.039 * 27 = 6,778,053
251.039 * 23 = 5,773,897 * 2 = 11,547,794
18,325,847 total
40 HL 425% * 50738 = 215,636.5 * 1.0995 = 237,093
237,093 * 22 = 5,216.046
237,093 * 18 = 4,267,674 * 2 = 8,535,348
13,751,394 total
120 LoD Hits 180% * 50738 = 91,328.4 * 1.0995 = 100,416
100,416 * 65 = 6,527,040
100,416* 55 = 5,522,880 * 2 = 11,045,760
17,572,800 total
1000 JoL Hits 20% * 50738 = 10,147.6 * 1.0995 = 11,158
11,158 * 543 = 6,058,794
11,158 * 457 = 5,099,206 * 2 = 10,198,412
16,257,206 total
70 Tyr's Hits 150% * 50738 = 76,107 * 1.0995 = 83,680
83,680 * 38 = 3,179,840
83,680 * 32 = 2,677,760 * 2 = 5,355,520
8,535,360 total
Grand total of 95,864,623 healing
makes it a loss of 1,161,977mil healing
It basicly comes down to this. If nearly half your healing done is critical strikes increasing that healing done by 5% is a rather big bonus. increasing say a Flash of Light(450% 50k int) that hits for 225k by 5% is 11,250 healing. That actually requires 2500 intellect. Which is a rather large amount. If you have average stat weights of around 1. that is still 2500 stats. And a cloak simply does not provide a lot of stats. You only gain 973 stats from switching to the 925 cloak.
Getting a 4piece would buff that amount. But if i take your 908k hps log from krosus You used 35 IoL on 11 HL and 24 FoL casts. Say all 42 of your FoL Casts where buffed so 18 of those 390k average casts where buffed by 50% you would gain 3.5mil on a 329mil healing done log. Where the math down below is showing a loss of 1mil per 100mil healing already. I simply don't think it's ever worth dropping the cloak. No matter what i play with on dreamguards spreadsheet i can't get ahead of the cloak.
Anyways i hope it helps Did see you questioning cloak on the discord but that's not really a place for replies like this.