*looks at VT role*
Pretty sure we have VTs!
*looks at VT role*
Pretty sure we have VTs!
Oh well, poor Crackle. Not much you could've done today.
I was LinkedIn if anyone cares.
Seeing as how Crackleslap is throwing in the towel in game I'm calling it. I'm tempted to call it a win for only Palawin (playing MySpace a Survivor) however I will begrudgingly give Town the win as well. I would like to say though that I did read Listo's posts #160/#163 as a possible violation of the rules and considered mod killing him after I read them but by the time I did it was too late.
Why did I read that as a violation? Anyone who could win with town (including the survivor) had a hidden ability:
Each night phase you will be asked to rank all players (including yourself) from most trusted to least trusted. Depending on how others vote, a player may be eliminated so vote carefully. You may not discuss how you are going to rank people at night in the main game thread!
Listo specifically asked in his QT early on D2 if he could talk about how he ranked people N1 the next day and was told no. That caused me concern that it was going to be a mass discussion so the following notice was quickly placed in all relevent QT's:
The group vig kill was used up last night so you will not be asked to rank anyone anymore. This ability is also hidden if you flip so you cannot talk about the fact that you were part of the team that was ranking people at night. But if you want to provide a trust/distrust list that is still allowed.
Seeing as how he chose to work his posts 160/163 it seemed like a pretty clear statement that he made a ranking list the night before. Unfortunately too many people interpreted his statements and tied it back to their role. I don't think it would have affected D1/D2 but made D3 much easier to choose a lynch target.
For those curious about the group vig kill...5 of 6 people ranked as asked on N1 (bad Palawin for missing that part of your role) and all placed Palawin as either their least trusted or second to bottom. This triggered an NK on him but as a survivor he had a collar/vest combo that would pop upon the first lynch/NK attempt.
Master thread with links to QT's is here.
https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/mxf5GwtMxPqww
Quick Role/QT List
Cop - Periscope - Monkz - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/hXiWS5amLgnet
Doc - Pinterest - Graeham - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/StNEmbTtVqpc
VT - Google+ - Arindel - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/endra8e8T73wx
VT - LinkedIn - Dupti - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/iiyrrbADTxB
VT - Tumblr - Listo95 - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/FRkBdgyEDr4
Survivor - Myspace - PalawinFC - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/iHhAcUZtRmTs8
GF - Facebook - Celtic - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/KEjCezxRLBWV
Goon - Youtube - Crackleslap - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/Swt9KYe22Aq2M
Goon - Snapchat - Cruelle - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/JwbMgkqXacENv
Group Chat - https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/ZPyrAKVi9Vj5i
Kryllian if that was to much it wasn't my intention. I literally asked if that meant I wasn't allowed to mention the ranking part at all. I never received another comment about that. I had asked a good 6 hours before those posts if even a mention of ranking was not allowed. If anything I would have said that should have been made more clear in the role card. If I never asked I would have thought mentioning making a list would be okay. But apparently I misinterpret stuff.
I was pretty sure the line was crossed by Listo claiming he'd made a list. I also thought arindel and myself probably broke the rule by acknowledging that we understand what he was hinting at.
Then on day 3 dupti hinted it too. Definitely made it extremely hard for scum. I don't think scum had much chance once that rule was broken... Although 3v6 was pretty scum favoured too, so maybe it balances out?
That said I have some feedback for Kryllian on the vigi mechanic. I love the idea but I think the rule not to talk about it was too stifling. Made it so difficult to talk freely and argue points, including about game make up. It was very very hard not to break the rule with out feeling very awkward.
I think a better resolution might be to have the vigi mechanic known about by scum as well (although they don't get to contribute to it), so it can't be used to indicate alignment.
All in all i really enjoyed this game. Never been a survivor before. I was pretty annoyed I lost my bpv on day 1. But game ended up being pretty short so I clumsied through it.
Thanks kryllian !
Thanks for running the game, Kryllian! I had a lot of fun and I'm glad I managed to avoid being lynched. I appreciate the players who supported me at such a critical point and that was a very intriguing play by Cruelle!
If I hadn't been killed on N2 I would have pushed on Dupti. I'm genuinely surprised he wasn't scum this time around.