Originally Posted by
Balrogix
Before I begin, I feel like I am force to state that I am against what happened in Charlottesville. Whoever charged the car against those people needs to be punished according to the law. I believe in equality in the sense that we should not treat anyone better or worst just because of their genitals nor because of the color of their skin.
I also believe in free-speech, which means that I believe that the counter-protests had as much right as the protesters to voice their opinion. I am against any unwarranted and unprovoked violence.
What we saw on Charlottesville is only going to escalate. For the past 11 months that is all that has been happening. Hell, for the past 2 years that is what has been happening. I've seen many pinpoint the origin of the alt-right problem as the election of Trump. But I disagree completely. Trump getting elected did not embolden the extremists on the right. It was not Trump's rhetoric that made them violent. What made the fringe groups within the right-wing act the way they are now were the extreme left ideologues that began putting the blame of all their problems on the "evil white capitalist man".
To be more precise, groups like Antifa and BLM have been spouting non-stop that "you are either with us, or against us", and throwing labels on anyone for the slightest disagreements. Over this period of time, words like sexist, racist and even Nazi have lost their value, due to the tactics employed by those two groups: "There are no bad tactics, only bad targets."
It doesn't matter how noble the origins of BLM were if they act like savages burning their own city (Baltimore), silencing any that criticizes them, justifying and cheering for violence against cops and white people, all the while calling anyone that disagree with their actions as racists. Then we have Antifa that have been making headlines since last year. They are at their best a bunch of vandals ready to destroy and pillage, and at their worst they are cultists, ready to lay down their life for their ideology. If you dare question them you are labeled a Nazi. And let us not forget about By Any Means Necessary (BAMN), which in recent years has literally become a cult!
All this groups have been rampart in this last two years, yet we have many defending them, saying it is ok to silence those that commit "wrong think". It is ok to assault someone because of their opinions. And then, whenever a group that is against any of them decides to make a protest, no matter how small, they show up and protests that were at first peaceful, become battlegrounds. The best example would be Berkeley.
Richard Spencer, no matter how low of a human being he is, no matter how despicable his views are, no one has the right to punch him when he has done nothing wrong. Punching Nazis when they didn't commit any crimes is not ok. Punching Antifa when they didn't commit any crimes is not ok. Punching BLM when they didn't commit any crimes is not ok. Punching anyone when they didn't commit any crimes is not ok. Unfortunately, we live in a society that have flexible morals, where having the wrong opinion is enough ground to remove any constitutional right they might have had.
And if you do hold a "wrong" point of view and you get silenced, people will cheer, pat themselves in the back because of how "virtuous" they are. But that is how you get extremists views to fester. That is how you make ideologues believe with even more fervor in their doctrines. You cannot kill ideas by silencing dissenters. That doesn't work and has never worked. Didn't work in Rome, didn't work under the USSR and will not work now. If you want to dismantle bad ideas you need to bring them to the light, you need to shine a spotlight on top of them and discuss them! You can only kill an idea with a better idea. It is not ridicule, it is not character assassination, it is not with violence!
The worst part? The far-left has been alienating people from both the center-left and center-right. Any that defends the rights of what the fringe groups on the left perceive as "The Enemy" is considered a sympathizer, and considering the leanings of this forum, I am sure someone will unironically call me "Nazi sympathizer" because I use nuance on my judgement.
Violence started because of the Extreme-Left, and now the extreme-right is answering it back. I have no doubts that they will in turn strike-back and things will keep on escalating. There are few ways now to defuse the situation, and most of them require a soul-searching from both groups. Unfortunately, many here will just dismiss it all as the other side's fault, claim that they are in the "right side of history" and perpetuate their actions, if not double down.