Hypocrisy by a Blizzard GM?

[Synros]

It would be nice if Identity Politics wasn't interjected into the game, like the cancer it is.

[Skulltaker]

Like skulltaker. Geez, some people. Amiright?

See here

[Thelyron]

If it were up to me, everyone that did not give their characters actual, fantasy-fitting names would be perma banned.

[clevin]

OP picks name that has overt political and social overtones. Wonders why it's controversial.

Shut up and change your name. Leave your political opinions out of the game.

[Eleccybubb]

It would be nice if Identity Politics wasn't interjected into the game, like the cancer it is.

Someone got banned for a name that is against the rules.

They then tried to be a smartass and keep what is essentially the same name.

Their own fault for the suspension.

- - - Updated - - -

Like skulltaker. Geez, some people. Amiright?

Clearly never heard of Warhammer it seems.

[Saffa]

Dude they have lesbian and gay people in wow, why give this guy a name change?

There are probably paedophiles in the game, it doesn't mean you can chose names that excite them. He was being 'clever' choosing a contentious name and then changing it to continue being 'clever'. He will probably grow out of it, or have a future as a politician.

[ONCHEhap]

GM is not an hypocrite.
the name should not have been reported,but still,rules are rules,and you have to obey them


OP however is one,trying to break the rules and act as a rebel then whine and throw a hissy fit when he has to face consequences

[Adoxe]

It's a dumb name, it doesn't matter what rules it broke. There are only two genders, no matter what someone believes, it should be left at that.

[Eleccybubb]

GM is not an hypocrite.
the name should not have been reported,but still,rules are rules,and you have to obey them

So if you have to follow the rules why should the name not have been reported if it clearly goes against those rules?

[Synros]

Someone got banned for a name that is against the rules.

They then tried to be a smartass and keep what is essentially the same name.

Their own fault for the suspension.

That literally has absolutely nothing to do with what I said...

[MoanaLisa]

I didn't see any hypocrisy. I did see someone asked to change their character's name trying to evade the request and then arguing about it.

If you have seen worse names then they likely have never been reported. Names that don't get reported don't get sanctioned.

And although people won't like this, it's true nonetheless in a general way: There are lots of grey areas around rules. Absolute black-and-white doesn't exist in all or even most cases. So there's some discretion and judgement involved. Different people will see things in different ways.

[urasim]

See here

I don't see how that proves you have the ability to pick a normal name when I clearly know that "skulltaker" isn't a "normal" name. Don't even know what you're trying to say to me with the link... If anything that name is against the terms of service for Blizzard, too.

[Durandir]

Here is the Naming Policy World of Warcraft

https://eu.battle.net/support/en/article/34530

Violations
Minor Violations

Minor violations include any names that:

Are trademarked or licensed by a company or an individual.
Consist of a string of letters which do not produce a pronounceable name (e.g. Asdfasdf, Jjxccm, Hvlldrm).
Consist of language existent only in online communication (e.g. Roflcopter, xxnewbxx, Roxxoryou).
Consist of any title prefix attached to a character's name, fantasy-based or not (e.g. Kingmike, Presidentsanchez).
Consist of any references to the real world, including people and places (Britneyspears, Newyork, Austinpowers).
Consist of a partial or complete sentence contained within the name (Hihowareyou, Ilikebeans).

Serious Violations

Serious violations include any names that:

Insultingly refer to other characters, players, Blizzard employees, or groups of people, be they in the game or external.
Include the names of any World of Warcraft® customer support representative or employee of Blizzard Entertainment (both real names and aliases).
Are mildly inappropriate references to human anatomy or bodily functions.
Are references to illegal drugs or activities.
Have racial, ethnic, or national connotations.
Have any connotations of major religions or religious figures (e.g. Jesus, Christianity, Buddha).
Include names of World of Warcraft realms, zones, or names of major characters from Warcraft lore.
Advertise any organizations or websites.
Are otherwise considered inappropriate for the game world.


Severe Violations

Severe violations include any names that:

Have any racial or ethnic connotations.
Have any national connotations.
Refer to extreme or violent sexual acts.
Refer to extremely violent real life actions.
Negatively refer to any aspect of sexual orientation pertaining to themselves or other players.
Are inappropriate references to human anatomy or bodily functions.
Are pornographic in nature.

[Machismo]

The person tried to get into a political argument with a GM. He clearly knew what he was doing, and just wanted to start shit. I've had ridiculous names that escaped scrutiny, and have had to change very mundane things for no apparent reason.

[urasim]

Clearly never heard of Warhammer it seems.

Clearly you don't know what "normal" means.

[blackblade]

So someone on the wow forums posted this link, asking how his name was not allowed.

Chat with the GM

Well, it dawned on me that this GM's words about "Gender identity not being for kids 12 and under" are contradictory to the fact, that this game has "suggestive content" that actually showcases this sort of thing to its players, which leads me to believe that the GM is full of shit.

For example, quests such as Unlikely Seduction, a quest about an NPC named Levia Laurence, who is depicted as being into fucking hot female demon ladies, show us gender identity; yet a player name called Twogenders is bad for some odd reason?

Hmm weird...

Oh wait no, twogenders actually goes against their belief in 63 genders! Yeah well, I guess saying there are only 2 genders might turn kids into homophobic haters or something... LOL

Basically, if you do or say anything against their beliefs you will have action taken against you.

Makes perfect sense right?

I'm a fair guy though, so let's have a friendly discussion!

Is this GM a Hypocrite in YOUR opinion?

If you look at the OP, you'll see that he hails from moon guard, an RP server.

RP servers have stricter naming policies than Normal servers requiring names that are moderately lore friendly.

[Eleccybubb]

Clearly you don't know what "normal" means.

How is Skulltaker not normal? Would actually fit a DH very well if you knew Illidans backstory.

[Onikaroshi]

Dude. Kind of had to fix that for you. That "Not" is kind of important. Because you know you wouldn't keep a name like that for long.

But yeah you call yourself a name like that then your own fault for whatever consequences.

Yea, one of those weird habits I have and it gets me into more trouble then I'd like, missing nots don'ts lol

[urasim]

Are inappropriate references to human anatomy or bodily functions.
Are pornographic in nature.

That means you can't have the name penis or vagina. You're really, really reaching.

[Sencha]

The name sucks and is not even funny. Why make a fuss about it?