I do not think Blizz will have a new LFG tool in game, but if one is not made as an addon, I can definitely see a discord server being made for it.
I can also see openraid coming back strong for PuG building.
I highly doubt people really want to spam trade chat these days when we have other tool to more efficiently build groups.
Shouldn't we differentiate between auto-matchmaking, that is the Dungeon/Raid Finders, from the bulletin boards, that is the Premade Groups?
Almost nobody would want automatic queues in a classic server, but Premade Group doesn't automatically do anything, doesn't teleport you anywhere and isn't all that different from a 3rd party website, except you don't have to tab out.
See here for my own Mage solo (and sometimes other classes too.)
And also see this document for my efforts at listing solo kills of every class. Please do not hesitate to message me if there is some kill I have failed to record.
Addons like the ones discussed in this thread should never have been allowed in the first place to function. Blizzard has already taken action against them and I hope and believe they will do it for classic too.
It's really as simple as making specific addons / addon functions against the rules and then enforcing it by banning players using them. Or simply by suing the creator of such addon, or even threatening it - I can guarantee no internet wiseass will fight for the right to draw dicks in the game with actual jail time on the line.
The best way to handle addons for Classic is in my opinion by disabling the use of the API for any external addons. Blizzard should then communicate with the community for a list of addons that were available during vanilla that they want, and bake them in to the client. These could then all be toggleable from the UI.
But Vanilla version is the most unlimited one o_O
Do you want fully automatic rotation bot w/o actually using a bot? Easy.
Do you want semi-auto 1 button UI? Easy.
And it'll be distributed w/ import strings a la WA
Stuff like LFG addons should be the least of people's concerns. Pretty much everything we had through history of WoW will be doable w/ Vanilla API, but it'll be much and much worse.
I think they threw in two people together and said "you're a group now, look for other people".
Aside from that, Instance Stones were hardly used at all, partly because you had to travel to the dungeon, click on the stone and then wait for it to happen, no one used that system.
People preffered to spam "LFG" in LFG Chat or respective zone of that instance.
That's an interesting question, actually. The Classic API allowed for far, far more powerful addons than today's. Will they restore it to where it was in vanilla? Restrict it to today's? They surely cannot disallow addons, threat meters at least were a core part of vanilla raiding.
But I'm pretty certain that, unless Blizzards seriously drops the hammer down, stuff like Oqueue and Openraids will be used in vanilla, a lot. There are only so many people who want to spam trade chat for half an hour.
I don't see the problem behind those things as long as it remains server restricted, you will constantly see familiar names rather than new ones.
It would sort of help to build a server community, people who constantly open raids will be recognized, get a bad / good reputation based on the raids quality and so forth.
Yeah right, innkeepers worked as well, but no system catched on until LFD ironically.
exactly my point's
unless the api is completely closed (in which case good luck cos the game was un playable without a threat meter at any respectable standard) then your gonna have DBM, oQue, weak auras, AV and all the outher addons that will make vanilla trivial and your just gonna have to live with that and live with knowing if you dont want to use it you will be at a disadvantage
Yeah, it's too late to introduce a somewhat similiar system when people are used to either /4 or /2
I guess that's why Dungeon finder was actually the only thing to conquer them both, because of the sheer convenience of not having to spam multiple chats and being TP'ed there
No x-realms was essential, hence there is no need (or application) for such AddOns.
All the little bits around vanilla raiding, looting, dkp, raid ids and so on kinda makes it imperative to keep it as it was.