Aaaand ofc the 2 set tier bonus deserved a 33% nerf
...... wtf? I guess they want us to be the bottom (or near the bottom) on dps? This makes no sense otherwise. And the 4-set will still not be desirable for any situation you're using Blade of Wrath. Wouldn't be surprised if they didn't fix the Divine Purpose 4-set bug, either. Awesome.
Yeah, it will matter, considering T20 4P is way ahead of T21 4P when using Blade of Wrath. Everyone would have been using the T21 2P, so it's just a straight nerf to every Ret. Every other melee does better in Tomb overall, so does it really matter if the tier they don't even have yet is nerfed more? No. It matters for us because we're at the bottom even with good T20 tier bonuses. Context is important.
Ret was never decent in ToS it was always bad and pretty much all the logs with any good numbers on them have a lot of retribution up time hence either people failed or worse yet people failed FOR them to get those logs.
As for survial there is nothing that AMS cant counter as well as bubble can but with the added bonus of being 1 min CD vs a 5min (unless you talent DI) at least on all the mythic encounters in ToS.
Also its funny u mention RNG as highlords is BiS atm for ret and it makes it heavy RNG to even pull your crappy dps atm ofc it may be less RNG than UH but you wernt exactly removing RNG. Better question is why you dident go for a arms warrior they are better made ret pala atm the only reason I stuck to my ret is that I mained ret since I started raiding SSC/TK back in TBC and even now I barely log it at all apart from to do raids I spend most of my time on my lock or hunter now.
let's be frank, though: Ret destroys both uh and frost on any kind of type of cleave or aoe.
But our cleave is crap...? Unless of course you think WoL is full of shit. According to their charts, our best fights are pure ST (Sisters, Maiden) without garbage anti-melee mechanics coughgorothcough, and mass AoE all day every day (Mistress), and the only one with a consistent cleave element where we do well is KJ, because he mercifully summons them on cue with our wings. Must be because he used to be a Paladin, so he knows what it's like.
OMG 13:37 - Then Jesus said to His disciples, "Cleave unto me, and I shall grant to thee the blessing of eternal salvation."
And His disciples said unto Him, "Can we get Kings instead?"