Originally Posted by
TheMediator
Make Brawler's Guild a semi-serious thing. Make EVERYONE want to do Brawler's Guild. Daily quest to defeat an optional boss at your current rank, and a weekly quest to defeat a progression boss (or a random bonus boss once you reach max rank). A new trinket that grows in ilvl as you progress in rank. Retune the fights and make it semi-clear what ilvl expectations there are for the fights at each rank. Reset player cooldowns after each match. Add in 'you go first if it is your first fight of the day' rule to allow people to drop it, get their daily or weekly done and peace out. Fix the arena space itself so there aren't camera issues.
Brawler's Guild does a wonderful job at spicing up the background of the game, you've got all these colorful characters and villains even if you only get a short introduction to them, a little sound byte from them on aggro, and a bit of dialogue on death, but it makes the game seem so much more alive, that there's more going on than the current raid tier, and I think that every player should experience it (and take it seriously to a degree, the thrill of clearing the hardest encounters in Brawler's Guild is only matched by the highest end of progression raid content).