Supple Helm of the Quick Blade 6/6 > Wild Gladiator Helmet in all stats
Crafted items is level 715 while PvP item is supposed to go up to 730 in PvP
I tested this inside of instanced PvP several times and each time the crafted item is superior in each and every stats that both share....
Edit: Its a tool-tip error, while comparing both items crafted shows as better my actual HP+stats are better with the PvP item...