Nighthold scaling (focus on spell blade aluriel)

[lucred]

Cross posting from wow forums for a larger pool of posters.

Ok, from what I understand enemy health is supposed to scale with the size of your raid. However, I was checking logs and it seemed that the adds for Spell Blade Aluriel normal had the same amount of health for a group of 27 as ours had for 11... This seems a bit off.

Can anyone from a large group (20-30) post how much health the fire adds have at that size? In our 11 man group they had 29m each.

If they do not have more it seems a bit off that they say to bring 10-30 people, but keep health/damage/number of targeted players the same no matter how many you have, so a 10 man group needs to put out 3X the damage per player that a larger group does.

[Aktec]

In our 24 man raid according to our log they took 369.38m dmg and theres 6 of them so 61.5m (ish) each
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...e&target=112.1

[Deja Thoris]

You can check this yourself on warcraftlogs pretty easily.

30 man 38.63m
10 man 12.46m
20 man 25.54

11 man 13.77m https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...ne&target=74.1

Can you link the logs where yours had 29m?

- - - Updated - - -

In our 24 man raid according to our log they took 369.38m dmg and theres 6 of them so 61.5m (ish) each

2 spawns would be half that. Unless you only had one fire phase which is unlikely.

[Aktec]

your link was hc deja op was asking for normal

edit: the fire adds have a lot less hp(about half) in heroic because you deal with them differently, so guessing thats where the op was confused between logs of different sizes.

[Fafnar]

I'm showing 3 sets of adds - Fiery, Icy, Arcane. Respectively they had 677, 451, 450 million health and Aluriel had 1.84b for the fight with 22 people in the raid.
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...en&hostility=1

[Aktec]

I'm showing 3 sets of adds - Fiery, Icy, Arcane. Respectively they had 677, 451, 450 million health and Aluriel had 1.84b for the fight with 22 people in the raid.
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...en&hostility=1

Your raid had 2 sets of fire adds spawn 56.25m each add with 22

[lucred]

My apologies... I do not know what happened, but when I check other logs it appears to scale. I just had the ONE log I checked with 27 people showed 9.2m dps with the fire adds last 31s for a total of 47m health per add or 1.76m health per add per player, versus our 2.63m health per add per payerl. When I check any other log it appears to be scaling up much faster (2.56m health per add per player) so I retract the objection I raised as it appears to scale almost as fast as raid size.

So the only issue is debuff overlap, and a small amount of extra dps compared to health since you don't have to keep taking up more spaces with tanks so a higher percentage will be dps.