Avatar, I'd give it an 8/10, I think it's a little TOO early for the Christmas hats. There's one month left for Christmas to came.
About the signature, I don't know what to say. I hate math, it's me second most hated class, if not the fist one. It is kinda well made, though, so I'm going to give it an 8/10.
Talking about doing doing stuff earlier than necessary, here's a pointless story. I had visited Metro like one month and half ago in Bucharest, and the employees were decorating a Christmas tree. I asked them why are they doing this so early, and the one in costume (probably some kind of boss, or something) said " Yes, sir, we know it's too early. But, we want to be the first ones this year!". :P
avatar 0/10. There is none. Even if you only represent your guild, make one with your logo :P
Sig 8/10. If you want it to make it cooler, make the boarders blur into the MMO board color, so that it looks like it's part of it.
I don't really know who your avatar is, but she looks amazing, so 9.75/10.
The signature is just text and stuff, so 3.5/10.
Avatar: 2/10 - sorry, just not into anime-ish stuff.
Sig: 7/10 - pretty well done =)
Ava: 9/10. I imagine that is your face whenever you reply to someone in the chat thread. I love it.
Sig: 6/10 Just not as good as the ava, it's still nice just not THAT nice
New ava/sig for me, looking forward to ratings! \o/
0/10 because I really really don't like that art, I don't know why
10/10 I love that art, I actually have that saved because it's just /so damn good/. Best Okuu art I've ever seen
Moar ratingz \o/
8/10 agree with Zefie, random hair ruins it.
10/10 love it.
<Anakso> I'd fuck yonghwa because he's so dreamy but that doesn't make me gay
4/10 Nice colours but anime doesn't do it for me.
2/10 No pictures! I like colours.
Perfect 10! I WIN!
(Also click the sleeping fox for another surprise)
7/10 for the Avatar, I know of the Doc but I've never watched the show.
9/10 for the Sig (A picture would have topped it off, but I like the quote)