So me and an (ex)friend got into an argument over which cloak is better for tanks. This argument ultimately ended our friendship coz he's an elitest asshole who thinks he knows it all coz he got carried through cata by transferring around to guilds who were already progressed.
The 397 tank cloak w/
The 397 caster dps cloak w/
Now my argument is that by reforging my 261 parry into 104 mastery, the tank cloak remains the better choice because I believe the mastery gain from going to the int cloak is not even remotely close to being worth losing 186 Strength, 157 Parry, and 127 Expertise. He on the other hand, is adamant that going with the int cloak and reforging the 166 hit into 66 Dodge is better. With the change to DS no longer refunding runes on missed death strikes, I feel that the expertise is worth keeping while he says I should reforge it into mastery (50). With my current reforges the way I think they should be done, I STILL have more parry than dodge w/o swordshattering, and would like my deathstrikes to not get parried nonstop so the runes are not wasted.
What is your guys' opinion on this. Which would you go with.