Reflective Shields + 4 pc T13

[Crunkosaurus]

So I was thinking about the combination of these 2, I've already been testing the numbers of Reflective Shields (Also apparently this can crit, which I didn't know about until it hit for 33k yesterday) without the 4 pc double-shield proc. With the potential for 80k+ PW:S that would mean that Reflective shields would also be stronger correct? (I know that this combination is very RNG as a whole, but i'd like to discuss it anyways)

It seems to me that with these 2 paired with atonement, disc is very nice for helping those tight enrage timers on HC's

Has anyone tried/kept track of either of these so we can get some numbers?

[Izzirez]

Reflective shields ONLY works when the shield is on you, and being directly attacked. Therefore, it would never proc in a raid environment unless you were tanking.

[Crunkosaurus]

Wow that totally rains on my parade. The tooltip of the talent is kind of sheisty in it's explanation, thanks for clearing that up. A mod can delete this if they see it, no point.

[Noradin]

It used to proc on any damage being absorbed by PW:S but was broken ages ago (in classic if i remember correctly). They never got around to make a better fix than to make it work (solely) on the caster again.
I don't know why we still have it in state it is in. Its worse than useless. It takes up space and has a misleading tooltip causing people to waste points if they aren't aware of its hidden shortcomings.

[Cymre]

I used to love the reflective shield for PVP but I agree it's now a waste of points for PVE purposes.