I like tanking and I like playing "good guy", so the choice was pretty much obvious. Also, Avenger's Shield is awesome, and so are guaranteed shield slam crits. And back in the day I leveled my character from 35 to 64 just by AoE Grinding all over the place. Good times!

Holy is fun every now and then, even though healing gives me a headache. Ret is... interesting, but I'm not a melee DPS kind of guy. So it's Protection Paladin all the way here.