But I agree with their assessment of Alchemist, and also agree on a lot of other DotA related stuff that those two talk about..
And I saw earlier that you do not watch pro-games, so I am guessing you are talking from pub stand point?.. That's quite differen't from competitive, and especially pro games. :P
Edit: With the lowest win-rate in pub games, and the most disliked hero..He is not that favored in pub games either. :9