After watching the Avengers, I couldn't thinking how Captain America resembles a Protection Paladin a lot. I guess the throwing of the shield is what really reminds of a protection paladin
Anways, Captain America is cool and just brutalizes with his shield. Since many of Protection Paladin spells are based on our shield, why not make Protection Paladins lose the one-hander?
My idea is that Protection Paladins should carry their Shield along with some small item that doesn't really do much, like how a relic works right now. Wouldn't it be cool with a tank that just runs around with a shield and fucking smashes everyone with it? Just like Captain America
Sure there would be issues since shields are offhands and offhand stats which would mean that having merely a shield as a main hand woul give your shit stats, but there is always ways around that.
CAPTAIN AMERICA!