Perfect example of why "community" forums are poisonous to the health of a development team. These developers are wasting hundreds of hours trying to stem the tide of incessant bitchery that would never, ever abate so long as these entitled, unfortunate human beings don't get their way.
Here is why I am puzzled about the Sha thing. I'll try to list my arguments in a manner where response can be much more convenient. I may update this post depending on any new ideas or feedback.
-Sha have Old God origins, however Twilight magic did as well.
-Priest can have a Sha spawn skin for their shadowfiend with the Sha-touched weapon, but the Warlock has a Sha-Skin tier on its own.
-In many instances, Sha whisper into your mind in Demonic in addition to having a couple of Sha classified as Demons.
-Many Sha spells are black/white versions of warlock spells. (eg Sha-(dow)bolt)
-Another interesting thing I have noticed is that despite their "emotional" origin, they tend to be a respected source of energy as well, given that the Sha energy ravaged the whole of Dread Wastes and Grand Magister Rommath siphoned that power and compared it to the FEL sensation and impact as an essence.
-Implementation of new Sha spells or glyph re-skins can be applied to shadow spells, mostly affliction and some to demo. Is it me or Touch of Chaos has a Sha vibe on it?
-I have noticed that the Sha have similar patterns to the Voidwalkers, in terms of spawning, reproducing and other spells they perform.
-An interesting theory might be that Warlocks and the Council of the Black Harvest aim for the mastery of the Sha, as an ultimate challenge to master one's self or as being the only ones that can bear that "burden". That can be elaborated by checking the leaked warlock questline where someone mentions: "Perhaps you can accept the disorder of this universe" and the Black Harvest has proved that they aim for every interesting source of power that appears.
Are the dreadsteads a actual race of demons and who is the strongest amongst them??
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it sounds like Sha magic is similar to the rules of the Heartless "magic" in Kingdom Hearts (Sorry, been playing it all through the Holidays). Powerful abilities that are strengthened by the raw, "dark" emotions (rage, fear, anger, hate.... Joy) and can be used for a limited time, but is near guaranteed to corrupt and ensnare the user, turning them into that which they wanted to control... Reason I bring this up is that there is a potential work around. Warlocks can't use Sha magic without becoming a lesser Sha themselves, right? What if Warlocks forced the change upon others they could control, and then use them as a proxy for the magic? Or, if there was a way to reproduce the processes that lead to Sha creation, creating artifical, weaker but more easily controlled, Sha? Guessing there's a reason it wouldn't work, but hey, two cents and the like.
Personally, I'd love to see if Warlocks are doing more harm than good in Pandaria. I mean, I know the general theme is that everyone is doing harm in some way, Paladins being overrighteous, Alliance and Horde fighting over the land, the Pandaren Shadopan being almost Happiness Patrol. But Warlocks are the ones that actively use negative emotions, Suffering, Anger and Chaos, as opposed to Mages "Lol, I know this, fireball" and Spriests "I r so great I make my own faith, lol I rhyme" (jesting). I'd be surprised if, in the end, we corrupt the Pandaren enough that Pandaren Warlocks become a choice.
---------- Post added 2013-01-01 at 04:44 PM ----------
Last edited by Queen Ultima; 2013-01-01 at 04:47 PM.
If this turns out to be canon, then would that mean that the whole Sha theme is entirely ruled out of the Warlock class? Or is there a possibility for it to appear in a minor expression through glyph alterations or a new spell?
I am afraid that the "inner counterbalance" refers to the light side priests have, where priests mastering the Sha sounds sad to me. I play both a warlock and a priest in terms of Warlock using dark powers and priest using spiritual power. However, if Shadowpriest master the Sha, it would be as if the scales favour the priest, due to the class having the most awesome/unstable dark power in the game along with the poetry that goes along with it.
In my opinion, priests may get sha influenced mind spells, while warlocks get to utilize even a bit of the essence.
they are possibly preparing warlocks for the next expansion. But will we play a big role or will a paladin go with the credits?
And will they finally give purpose for the warlocks serving horde and alliance?
(no lock can be trusted atm, maybe they will add a branch in their lore about warlocks solely using demonic magic to master it due to a prophecy they'll have to face strong legions of sargeras?)
Sie sind das Essen und wir sind die Jäger!
remember: cata foreshadowing began at WotLK's launch with obsidian sanctum and the twilight drakes
Sha should never be a warlock theme. They can try for it, but they should fail. Warlocks have been greedy thematically lately. They have twilight(affliciton), demons(demonology) and elemental fire(destruction). Let some other specs get something.
The sha fit shadow priests the most in-game. It even mentions in Cdev answers #3
Shadow priests use negative emotions. Sha use negative emotions. They were made for each other. Shadow priests need the lore too, they haven't got any in-game lore, and the Cult of the Forgotten Shadow doesn't seem present in-game very much and it's only really mentioned in the WoW magazine.The Light is often said to bring about feelings of positive emotion— hope, courage, comfort— and the like. Shadow abilities are just the opposite, able to impart feelings like despair, doubt, and panic.
That said, I agree sha shouldn't have ANYTHING to do with warlocks, it makes absolutely zero sense - all it is is dark and edgy people wanting a completely unrelated theme tied into their class "because it looks cool". If anyone gets it it should be spriests, since it fits them thematically, but even then - EVERY lore we have seen so far indicates that sha can not be controlled, all of it.
There is zero lore reason to back up sha being tied to a class, especially warlocks. Makes about as much sense as making warlocks necromancers, it's not what the class is about. If you want to play something else, go play something else, don't go twisting a fanfic-ing a well established archetype into something it's not.
I am personally afraid that the way this is going to be presented will be harmful to other casters, like how you always thought priests are more subtle and more...priestly. Now look at them, they can unleash a torrent of internal struggle that can devastate anything it can touch. It sounds to me like a more modern and well written idea of a dark theme that happened to get to a class that lacked lore but will make other classes like locks look worse at what they are good for.
You don't roll a warlock because you want to play an undead-summoner, nor a sha-controller. If you clicked it expecting either of those, you clicked the wrong button. There's no room in the class for for ramming necromancer or sha thematics without diluting the very soul of what the class is, regardless of how many people see flashy now things and think it would be great to ram them into an existing class "because it looks cool".
Besides, Warlocks are still throwing around the tools of the Legion, which have ended worlds and corrupted a bloody Titan - creating what is arguably WoW's endgame. I have zero reason to feel inadequate because a priest is dabbling in things that can corrupt a mere region of an island.
That said - I still don't see the point in "giving" sha to anybody, nor do I think priests getting a cosmetic effect this tier is any more of an indication that they'll be getting sha thematics than the Firelands staff was that druids would be getting fire ones. It's something fun, fancy and fitting for the tier, I'd be surprised if it was some overarching class development (though I could be wrong). Everything shown ingame so far and things Xelnath have said all point to sha being completely unusable and uncontrollable, from the questing to the raid bosses in 5.0, the 5.1 quest line to the part of the green fire quest Xelnath mentioned - everything has indicated that they're absolutely impossible to control and just corrode and corrupt anyone who tries.
the sha matches priests better than warlocks, because they are masters of manipulating the mind and the hearts of people, which is where sha comes from.
but it does match warlocks well too. warlocks get power from wherever they can take it, and they do have the strength of will to master any type of dark power, rather than be consumed by it. spells like Unending Resolve and Unbound Will add to that.
just like shadow priests and warlocks shared the twilight motif (with shadow priests taking most of it), they could also share the sha. anyone can summon the sha, after all (even warriors, as long as they are in pandaria). warlocks got the sha set, priests got the sha minion. seems fair to me
a) Everything in lore has depicted sha as being completely uncontrollable
b) Warlocks deal with demons, it's what the class is. They don't get power "wherever they can take it" in that sense, otherwise they'd have absolutely no character, they'd just be an amalgamation of various bits 'n bobs gathered each expansion - we didn't go picking up undead thematics, despite necromancy being a perfectly attainable skill. We shouldn't be picking up sha thematics, especially since all lore has shown that it isn't a skill that can be attained. Mantid, Pandaren, the best in the horde - all failed to control the sha and ended up coming out of the other end worse off for it.
Classes need character, you can't just go diluting it by shoehorning every flashy thing an expansion churns up into it, especially when it directly counters the very essence of said enemy and has no correlation to the class you're trying to ram it in to.
I can kinda get the priest thing - shadow has lots of emotion thematics, but even then it's a stretch to imagine they can tame something that has been depicted in every depiction as being uncontrollable. People wanting sha-themed warlocks are making ridiculously asinine arguments though. I get it - you like how sha look, the infinite dragonflight looked cool too, doesn't mean we should become infinite dragonflight handlers.