The "too realistic" game does not exists.
None of the current games are realistic. Not even close.
And the games that were more realistic than others just 5 years ago, now look like a piece of crap.
Nothing in the game industry is realistic. Physics is not realistic, graphics is not realistic, AI is not realistic, sounds are not realistic, even npc dialogs are not realistic.
Some people like cartoon graphics. Like some people like to sometimes watch a cartoon instead of a movie.
But thats it. It does not mean that any of the current games are "too realistic".