Last edited by momirmaster; 2012-10-08 at 02:28 AM.
In my opinion Exodus, who are undoubtedly a good guild, are not good enough to make a serious impact on the race. Also taking into account that Exodus, who had a whole gear reset over Paragon and Method in T13, couldn't even finish ahead of those guilds with a huge gear advantage. So how do you expect them to come anywhere near the top Euro guilds this Tier when everyone has an equal start.
1. Paragon have gone through a major roster change. They are either HUGE favorites or underdogs.You know nothing. Not flaming just telling it like it is.
Firstly, Paragon the underdogs? If anything they are stronger as they dont have to put up with raiding 25 man.
Blood Legion as a favourite? Lol. They have never had a single world first. They arent anything more than a realm first guild.
Envy is basically Ensidia without Kungen? Envy made their name a long time and are a strong very hardcore guild in their own right.
Nihilum? Im sorry, have you seen Kungens stream? Wiping for days on normal modes, still trying to get a decent roster with HM's knocking on the door they are anything but a world first guild.
From what I can see is that you have based everything off of nothing, watching twitch.tv doesnt make you an expert on a world first race.
2. You are not giving Blood Legion the credit they deserve. They are the best of the US by a country mile and in my opinion are just as good as Method.
3. I am fully aware of Envys history. However Ensidia were a far superior guild to Envy, thats a fact, So basically the guild is Ensidia without Kungen.
4. I know Nihilum don't have a chance at world first. However it is disrespectful not to give them a mention seeing as they are the best guild of all time in terms of progression and world first kills.
If 25 man encounters aren't tuned quite a bit easier than 10 man, Paragon will most likely get world first, simply because they probably have the best 10 player team overall. Their 25 man team was extremely strong for sure, but if you take the best 10 out of those (who might or might not be in that 10 man team now) and let them compete against other 10 man guilds and against other 25 man teams (which in terms of overall performance will never touch the top 10 of Paragon), Paragon will win hands down.
Time will tell if it's really Paragons top 10 playing this tier tho.
Oh and don't forget, most likely the most important world first will be Sha of Fear, as the final raid boss, which is atleast 1 month away from now (given they would clear everything the first week heroics unlock), and not everyone will have as much time for all those weeks, RL issues, jobs and the like.
Due to the gated layout of T14, this race will be vastly different from any other so far.
Wow, so many opinions on leading raiding guilds...
I guess it's like football. You have to be specially interested to form such opinion of them all. I am sure if we get someone else with a different favourite, we'll get a completely different "review" of each guild.
Not super interested but I'd root for Method.
Even after I got declined. WAT?!
Last edited by Mifuyne; 2012-10-08 at 06:01 AM. Reason: y u no show signature?
It doesn't make sense to mix 10 and 25 man guilds since these are completely different things. "World first" is a meaningless concept in the current game, only "World first 25 man" and "World first 10 man" make sense.
Method better put all those world boss kills to good use...
I mean, from a "fan" stand point, I'm rooting for Blood Legion, just because I'm a US player. Honestly of Raiding guilds (I'm way more in to PvP players with rankings and stuff), I'm a biggest fan of 'Months Behind' on I think Eradar. They're not a top 10 guild but I follow them for personal reasons. Anyway, From a "WoW" Perspective I'd like to see Method up there for sure. I think Kin Raiders are tight, even if their Spine kill was psuedo-rigged with mages. I like Vodka too.
Exodus for world first best looking men.
---------- Post added 2012-10-08 at 06:35 AM ----------
Give me vanilla raiding where shit is just released and we have to figure out everything without a dungeon journal or having months to see everything.
This time round in MOP, the China realm is just 1 week behind the rest of the world. If there are any tough bosses that requires many hours of attempts (such as Yogg-0), then they may stand a chance in the world first race.
Note: STARS is playing on TW server for MOP, which are 2 days behind US in term of raid week.
A truth that will be burried ofc under tons of 10 man advocates, in case a 10 man clear the tier faster than anybody else.
In short, they are two different races, since we re talking about two different modes.
Blizzard themselves talked about "offering 2 different raiding experiences".
If they 're different they re not the same (wondering how so many and for so long can't see and aknowledge this obvious truth).
Hope that they will at last seperate the achievements to put an end to this pointless discussion.
I mean they are "offering two different sizes for two different raiding experiences" but they re treating them for 2 years as the SAME, and at the same moment they designed a system that allows you to experience either the one, or the other!
It is the definition of paradox!
But then again, we are talking about a system that was designed to offer "an easier aproach to end game" for all.
As such, pretending that they are the same, is not so outrageously uncomprehentable.
What it is outrageous with this system, is that it encourages the truth to be twisted, and it has been twisted, systematically, for more than 2 years now, ever since the changes have been announced, back in the summer of 2010.
On the matter, i was able to see that KIN, Method, Blood Legion and Stars were able to maintain their roster. As such, in my opinion, they re the favorites for the 25 man world first.
I would add Envy next to them, but with Kungen back in the game, i have a big question about the stability of their raiding team regarding the members of ex Ensidia.
Even without them though, they should be a strong outsider.
Nihilum if they manage to form a competitive team in the end, wont stand a chance for the current tier. Maybe we will have to consider them from tier 15 and further though. I have strong belief that Kungen's managerial skill and popularity can attract some of the greatest players in this game to join his team. It is left to be seen though if he means business .
For the 10 man, 2 ex 25 man guilds Paragon and In Extremis (In Extremis was world 4rth ICC 25 heroic team) are the undisputed favorites for the world first!
Last edited by Archidamos; 2012-10-08 at 09:52 AM.
The first Tier is all about how many Alt Raids you did to equip your Mains - Or how lucky you were.. take a look @ the hardcore Guilds.. its ridiculous how much Loot they already have
if you cannot play u are fucked anyway.