Do not use the Brawler's Statue, there is no point explicitly chasing avoidance.
You have two rational options --
1. Pursue 7.5% hit and 7.5% expertise, then mastery.
2. Pursue 7.5% hit and 15% expertise, then mastery and/or haste.
Your trinkets should never be avoidance, and in general avoidance should be reforged away on all gear. The only trinkets that make sense right now for serious content are stamina and mastery (as far as proper tank trinkets go).