2:Jaina defended Darnassus killing intruders before a sunreaver shows the horde how to bypass those defences, so Jaina punishs the sunreavers for breaking neutrality, which she did just prior.
Rhonin himself vouched for the Thalen and Aethas vote made it possible for Jaina to become the leading member of the six.
She broke the neutrality in Darnassus she had the city in lock down, disposing of every charlatan that tried to slip through and it seems a sunreaver helped to bypass those defences.
It is fun that you call me fanboy, even though I stated several times in this thread that she made the right decision, was it a biased one of course it was, but still right. But as it seems you were too lazy to read most of the thread and decided to make an ignorant poorly thought through post, if you want a discussion you should get your facts straight.