Would definitely choose the Logitech G600 over Razer Naga. The mouse is simply superior in every way, especially when it comes to the laser sensor.
Upgraded from a Naga to a G600 last month. Seeing as they have the same price I would go with the logitech. Everywhere I look everyone has the same issue I was having, the double click issue. That's not poor quality control, that's terrible quality control.
I have to say i am loving the extra keybinds compared to the naga. I just wish it was more comfy for my smaller hands. Need to decide soon.
I've used both Logitech and Razer mice. I prefer logitech as from my experience, they feel better, last longer, and feel more natural for long gaming. my current mouse is the G700.
i REALLY want to get a g600 but im extremely hesitant due to the gshift button... i seem to hold my mouse strangely... on my naga molten my thumb is obviously on the grid, the next finger is on left click, my middle finger always sits on the scroll wheel, the next finger on right click and little finger grips the other side of the mouse, with my grip style and g600 my little finger would be on the gshift key or id have to change my grip which im unsure if itd be comfy... sadly i cant try before i buy so im hesitant to drop the cash...
Gorgeous sig by Jassinta
CPU: Intel i5-3570k (4.5GHz) MB: ASUS Z77 Sabertooth (uefi 2003)
GPU: Asus 280X TOP (1080MHz/1700MHz) RAM: Corsair LP/LV white 8GB 1600MHz
SSD: Samsung 840Pro 256GB + Crucial m4 128GB (040H) PSU: Seasonic 620M CASE: Corsair 500R (White/Black) Monitor: LG 237L-BN IPS
Current build! ||Old Build || Bitdefender Windows 8 Security 2013 || AV-TEST Jan/Feb 2013
The only thing that made me choose the G600 > Naga is the G-Shift button, which in BF3 I have programmed to be SHIFT for steadying scope, In MW I have it set to autocenter Xhairs - derp noscope 101, wow I use it as a mobile rotation macro. It made sense in store and at home so Im happy. I also frequently multibox, having all my multibox binds at my thumb is great as well.
I replaced my Razer Naga with a G600 a couple of months ago due to my Razer Naga right click going wonky, and I have to say so far I love it, solid & comfortable, the bevel on the 1st 6 buttons and 2nd 6 buttons means that it's actually more intuiative to find your way around all 12 buttons with your thumb.
The only thing that annoyed me was the 3rd clickable top button (next to the right mouse button) that I easily disabled via the logitech software.
If i was to give the Razer Naga 7.5/10, I'd give the G600 9/10.
The build quality feels so much sturdier than the Naga, and the Naga wasn't bad.
Everytime my Naga went out, i would just go buy another. Thinking about giving the mouse a go. Without even knowing it, more and more of my peripherals, have logitech on them.
<p align=center><a target=_blank href=http://www.nodiatis.com/personality.htm><img border=0 src=http://www.nodiatis.com/pub/18.jpg></a></p>
I must admit, I'm probably going to jump on a G600 next when my Naga dies. As much as I love it, I just really like the G600 after using it a few times. It's not a 'must do now!' kind of switch, more just a future change for me, unless Logitech releases something else in the mean time.
I switched from a Naga to a Steelseries Sensei and I LOVE it.
The G600 seems like the better mouse as far as build quality and features go. The buttons are significantly more tactile, it has a superior laser, it has onboard memory, and you can presumably get twice as many hotkeys out if it with the G-Shift feature.
From my experience with these mice, there are only two reasons to get a Naga over a G600:
First, sensor preference. Both are flawed, but in different ways. The Naga's Philips Twin Eye sensor has z-axis problems. If you lift the mouse off of your mousepad/desk/whatever, your cursor sometimes takes off and repositions itself on an edge or corner of your screen. The G600's Avago ADNS-9800 has no liftoff problems, but doesn't have perfect 1:1 tracking. This laser has a weird and very slight acceleration (~5%). It's not a big deal in most cases, but certain things (FPS gaming is the big one) really require better precision.
Second and more importantly, the shape. The Naga is a very small mouse that is better suited to a fingertip grip. I'm sure it can be palmed, but the small size would probably make it somewhat straining. The G600 is much bigger and is really designed only for a palm grip. The third finger button makes it too wide to hold comfortably with your fingertips.
Yeah, I've settled on this for now too. I have quite a few gaming mice and I'm happiest with the Sensei. I'd really like to get a Zowie AM, but at the same time I actually really like my hard mousepad. Not sure if the accuracy is worth going back to cloth.Originally Posted by Corzaftw
By the way, I've got both versions of the mouse and much prefer the RAW to the original. The side buttons are more even, textured, and buttons 6 & 7 actually work properly without the software running. Maybe my original one was just a first batch that's been improved on though.
As a G600 owner its not the best mouse for FPS at all, but it does the job well enough. I actually don't mouse/keyboard snipe anyways, Xbox 360 controller is quite honestly a ton easier in BF3 especially if your trying to snap scope, and if your not an owner of a joystiq etc the 360 controller is superior in every way possible to mouse and keyboard for flying anything.
do you not use the G-Shift + 12 side buttons binds in WoW?
I have G600 and have not had any problems with it yet. The jumping issue was resolved through a firmware update quite a while ago, I believe. Or it was due to some setting which also got fixed. Don't quote me on this, though.
Software wasn't as intuitive as I had expected, but I've never tried anything like this before so maybe that's normal.
The side buttons are easy to press, except for 10 and 11; Those two require me to bend my thumb a bit too much unless I use claw grip. The G-Shift button is as natural as the first two once you get used to it.
Due to the extra button, it's wider than most mice and that's better, at least for me.
Last edited by Creotor; 2012-10-29 at 04:51 PM.