Healing trinket comparison

[Kalmah]

I don't know if something like this has already been made, this is a quick summary of healing trinkets (ilvl476+) that are available. ICDs are taken from wowhead comments which link to blue posts.

Spirits of the Sun (H) ilvl 509 - 1300 int, 7796 spi 20s, 105s ICD
Average stats: 1300 int / 1485 spi

Qin-xi's Polarizing Seal (H) ilvl 502 - 1218 spi, 3653 int 20s, 45s ICD
Average stats: 1623 int, 1218 spi

Spirits of the Sun ilvl 496 - 1152 int, 6908 spi 20s, 105s ICD
Average stats: 1152 int, 1315 spi

Jade Courtesan Figurine ilvl 489 - 1079 int, 3595 spi 15s, 60s CD
Average stats: 1079 int, 899 spi

Qin-xi's Polarizing Seal ilvl 489 - 1079 spi, 3236 int 20s, 45s ICD
Average stats: 1438 int, 1079 spi

Scroll of Revered Ancestors ilvl 489 - 1079 int, 3595 spi 15s, 60s CD
Average stats: 1079 int, 899 spi

Spirits of the Sun (LFR) ilvl 483 - 1021 int, 6121 spi 20s, 105s ICD
Average stats: 1021 int, 1166 spi

Relic of Chi Ji ilvl 476 - 1157 int, 3027 spi 20s, 45s ICD
Average stats: 1157 int, 1345 spi

Qin-xi's Polarizing Seal (LFR) ilvl 476 - 956 spi, 2866 int 20s, 45s ICD
Average stats: 1274 int, 956 spi


Regen ranking :
Spirits (H) > Relic of Chi Ji > Spirits > Qin-Xi's (H) > Spirits (LFR) > Qin-Xi's > Qin-Xi's (LFR) > Jade Courtesan Figurine = Scroll of Revered Ancestors

Throughput ranking :
Qin-Xi's (H) > Qin-Xi's > Spirits (H) > Qin-Xi's (LFR) > Relic of Chi Ji > Spirits > Jade Courtesan Figurine = Scroll of Revered Ancestors > Spirits (LFR)

Qin-Xi's is the only trinket which has static spirit with an int proc rather than the other way around. While the average int is very high compared to other trinkets, I don't really like throughput procs as a healer.


Overall I think the BiS setup is Relic of Chi Ji + Spirits of the Sun (any version)


Let me know if I made a mistake somewhere.

[Whicker]

I hate asking this as i should be able to do it myself, but if someone could figure out the MP5 of each trinket including rapture procs for disc that would be awesome!

[Deleted]

Bear in mind most, if not all, of those trinkets have a 15% proc chance. Consequentially averaging like that gives a distorted view of how much stats you're actually getting. For example Qin-xi is suppose to have a ~44% uptime but I usually end up with 35-40%. The same can be said for Relic of Chi Ji & the other trinkets. When you bear this in mind Qin-xi is actually probably the best regen trinket out there.

I would probably go with Qin-xi & Spirits of the Sun. Chi Ji is obscenely good for its ilv though.

Jade Courtesan Figurine really needs a buff...