What games caused you the most wear n tear or even resulted in breaking your controller? (from the mechanics of the game not throwing the controller in a rage of fury)
Ones that come to mind to me are,
Crash n the Boys street challenge for NES. (Button mashing in all its glory.)
And the tug-o-war mini game from Mario Party which easily can result in a broken joystick and a giant red bleeding circle on your palm!