We're 4 people playing together once a week. We've just played through Borderlands (1) and are looking to start something else up. Borderlands 2 would be a logical choice, but I'm wondering if there's something else people could recommend, to try something different? We have also played Diablo 3, but one playthrough was enough, though that was great fun as well.
We're only playing 3-4 hours a week, so it should be something you can get some progress in during that limited time. Not all of us are the most uber players, specially in regards to fps games, so the difficulty shouldn't be too high (or configurable). We had to partly outlevel Borderlands (like 2-3 levels above) to get decent progression.
If there's any story or character progression then that's a plus, we're all former role players.
And preferably not with a monthly fee.
Edit: We're all playing on PC