Should he be re-instated? No. Should he be whipped 1,000 times in the nuts for every one time he beat his daughter? Yes. Beating your child is horrible in itself. Beating your *disabled* child while you are ironically a freaking judge of all people is even more sickening. It's also sickening to know that sick fucks like this have very important not to mention well-paying jobs while better people that don't beat their children are having a hard time even finding work to support the family they don't abuse.