But what about a mod-based tribunal? Meaning, it takes 3 mods to authorize a poster's infraction. It would be easy to implement: someone reports a post, and if 2 out of the first 3 mods to review it vote for infraction, then the infraction passes. It would somewhat balance out moderator bias.
Just brainstorming here, don't crucify me.
My Gaming Setup | WoW Paladin (retired) "This is not a dress. This is a sacred robe of the ancient psychedelic monks."
If you see something against the rules, report it.
If you want to be more involved to help the forum in a greater capacity, apply to be a mod.
If you're unhappy with an infraction, get other mods to evaluate the fairness of the infraction by appealing it on the ban appeal forums (if you're currently banned) or by asking a mod to put up an infraction appeal (if not banned).
If you're unhappy with a particular moderation decision or something systematic, PM me with links to specific examples.
We're not going to encourage witch hunts and naming and shaming here. We have proper channels that can handle moderation work fine as is.