So, me and my guild are right now stuck on Garalon for a second week. We didn't have any problems on any of the previous bosses (we managed to down Elegon quite easy, have no problem with Vizier or Blade wall), but on this guy, we've hit a bloody brick wall. Today we managed to get him to 9-10%, but we died due to enrage (We were going 2 tanks, 3 healers, 5 DPS, switching at 20-25 stacks.). We also tried to do it with 1 tank and 6 DPS, but something always got screwed up. (carriers dieing, off-tank DPS dieing to swipe). We have yet to try 2/2/6 setup, but we don't think it's optimal for this guy.
To clarify, we are always focusing the legs when they come, even the melee. We pop BL at the beginning, I'm popping Stormlash and Elementals on CD, keeping searing totem up otherwise.
The raid setup is the following
Blood/Frost DK (the guy who switches)
Resto Shaman (me)
Thanks for the help, if you need me to link armory and such stuff, will do it .